Alexanders On The Water
Cicero, IN • 4.3 (496 Google reviews)
The Story
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Fatima
• a month ago
High recommendations by a friend to try ice cream at Alexander’s on the water and it was good. The views, outdoor seating, family friendly atmosphere and huge portions are a plus at Alexanders on the Water. We were a group of 7 adults, 4 kids and 2 pups so our order took about 30 minutes give or take with wait time ordering and picking up the ice cream. We didn’t mind cause we were enjoying our Saturday evening and wrapped up with a walk on the bridge. I would say service is excellent and ice cream is good. Do try it for a nice change of area and pace.
Alicia
• a year ago
First time trying Alexanders. Got a butterscotch chocolate chip tidal wave. I was thinking it would be similar to a blizzard. That was not the case. It was thinner than a milkshake and didn't taste that great. Tried my husband ice cream and it was okay.
Ralph Berry
• 3 months ago
Considering what this is, please view the 4 rating as very strong. A 4 means good, and that is exactly what this place was. We were renting on Morse a few blocks away and wanted some basic sandwiches to bring back to the house. They have enough variety to satisfy all of our interests. Walked up and placed the order. Trouble is, about 20 high school age kids came up right after, all ordering just ice cream. It was obvious that this overwhelmed the staff as they scrambled to fill the orders. I think getting ice cream out somehow got ahead of getting the meals out, so my order took a while. Still, if on the lake or in the area, this beats fast food and is supporting a small local business.
Linda
• a month ago
First off love the waffle cone and price but the butter pecan ice cream want actually horrible. No flavor. Like eating vanilla. Bummer