← All stops

Applegate Farm

Montclair, NJ • ★ 4.5 (3508 Google reviews)

Inside Applegate Farm
Applegate Farm photo from Google
Applegate Farm photo from Google

The Story

This is the flagship stand for ice cream made on a farm dating from the 1840s.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Deepty Murty (13)

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    Summer staple .. this is a must visit in the beautiful 🤩 neighborhood of monclair. The menu is vast and service is fantastic. Their fudge is the best in my/Nj area. Personally love cherry vanilla (sugarless version is my fav) and Strawberry 🍓. It’s made with real fruits. All the ice creams are made with best quality ingredients. There plenty of parking and some spots to sit and enjoy the icecream

  • Manan Shah

    ★ 5 • 5 months ago

    Had a really nice experience at Applegate Farm Creamery. One thing I really appreciated was that most of their ice cream flavors were egg-free, except for the yellow cake batter flavour. Great to see that level of transparency and variety. We tried the coconut and strawberry ice cream, and both were delicious. The coconut was rich and refreshing, while the strawberry tasted fresh and full of flavor. They also have a lot of other options on the menu, and I’m definitely planning to come back to try one of their sundaes next time. It is a bit on the expensive side, but the portion sizes are huge, so it feels worth it.

  • NapturalDivas2Adore Journey

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    I scream, you scream, we all scream for ice cream, and guess what? My sister and I finally visited Applegate Farm! It’s so sad that we’ve been just 8 minutes away since 1999 and never made it. But hey, better late than never! I decided to come on Father’s Day to try their Graham Central Station and Cookies and Cream flavors. They were absolutely delicious! I even went back on a solo trip a week later just to try the Graham Central Station again, which is my absolute favorite. It’s so good that I might get in trouble with these several trips I plan on doing this summer to try all of their other flavors, but hey, what’s wrong with a little treat now and then🤭? I’ll definitely be back again and again! 😋

  • 7amadaDe3o

    ★ 5 • 4 months ago

    Applegate Farm is an absolute hidden gem! The ice cream tastes so homemade and delicious, and the portions are HUGE. About $8 for two flavors....unbeatable for the quality and amount you get. Friendly staff, fast-moving line, and 100% worth the wait. I’ll definitely be back again and again! 🍦😍