← All stops

Blacksmith Ice Cream Co.

Millcreek, UT • 4.7 (560 Google reviews)

Inside Blacksmith Ice Cream Co.
Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. photo from Google
Blacksmith Ice Cream Co. photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Cory Edwards

    • a month ago

    In a world that seemed like you’d never need a new ice cream spot for Utah comes Blacksmith. I’ve been hearing about it for months, so after dinner in SLC we went. L It’s good ice cream. Very creamy. Not icy at all. The biggest problem Blacksmith has is that they have fairly limited gluten free options. You can’t even get a chocolate ice cream (except dairy free). So they will need to work on better addressing. C The Lavender Honey and the Carmel Cashew are good, but not what I would have wanted to select.

  • Kymble Johnson

    • 4 months ago

    I think this is the best ice cream place in UT!! You’re not overwhelmed with too many options, and all the flavors look (and taste) amazing. Big shoutout to the monthly/seasonal flavors, they are usually to die for. Good ambiance, great staff, and love good portion size. A lot of times there is a line out the door when it gets later, so keep that in mind!

  • Lindy Wilde

    • 5 months ago

    Blacksmith Ice Cream offers quality fresh flavors. I’ll admit that I was disappointed by the quantity of ice cream in respect to the cost. We got a flight of ice cream and two scoops were half the size of the others, and the others were quite small to begin with. The setup is fun we love the artwork on the walls and the seating upstairs. We tried raspberry and lemon bar- both incredible. Appreciated the cookie one and felt meh about s’mores.

  • Komson Chanprapan

    • 5 months ago

    The best ice cream in town. Very creamy and sticky. What I like the most is that it’s not overly sweet. Their mocha cold brew was definitely my favorite. The store is very open and well decorated. The staff can be a but friendlier though. I will definitely be back and recommend this place to anyone.