← All stops

Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

Brooklyn, NY • 4.5 (1477 Google reviews)

1920
Inside Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain photo from Google
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain photo from Google
Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain photo from Google

The Story

The old Longo's pharmacy sat shuttered for decades until a brother and sister scrubbed the tin ceiling, kept the apothecary cabinetry and put a marble counter back to work. The Sundae of Broken Dreams — salted caramel over vanilla — is the one everyone photographs, but the chocolate egg cream is the soul of the place.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Alison Pouw

    • 2 months ago

    adore this spot. reminds me of la farmacia in uruguay - old pharmacy turned ice-cream shoppe in this case though. fantastic ice cream and presentation and unforgettable vibe. we got the dubai chocolate sundae though everything looked incredible. always happening at any time and will be back to try so much more. play some games in the back if you get the chance or pick up the new york encyclopedia.

  • Ari Ziegler

    • 2 months ago

    My favorite spot in Brooklyn! I love the Farmacy and all that it has to offer. From amazing ice cream and seasonal flavors to the beautiful old timey interior, it’s such a special spot that I return to every time I’m in the area. I especially love the potato head sundae and the banana split! But also don’t forget to try and egg cream and hibiscus float.

  • Dan Levy

    • 3 months ago

    Pricey, but enjoyable and nostalgic. Lots of great options for sundaes on their menu, most if not all of which are designed for sharing. We were seated/served in minutes during our mid day visit, although we’ve walked by and seen lines out the door at night. The warm brownie sundae was exactly as it’s intended - warm, cold, sweet and fudgey. Love the ambiance of the place too. Recommended!

  • M. W.

    • 3 months ago

    I preface this by saying my friend and I came at a very busy time (9:45pm ish on a Saturday). I would definitely come back here for the ice cream and quality of the yummy items. However, it was quite stressful to sit at the bar. There were quite a few staff working at the time, but the flow of the bar back area was so chaotic to watch. One of the staff kept taking deep breaths, another put dirty dishes in front of us on the counter. Someone clocked out, and we watched him change behind an employees only door that looked like where Harry Potter was forced to live at his uncle’s house as a child. At the time we came, it wasn’t possible to make our items with care, or to provide friendly service at the bar - there were too many customers. But just writing this because it gave me pause to come again, especially at this time of day. Perhaps more of the ice cream making can be done in the back kitchen, and the number of staff can be split up in an organized way. I just hope staff are considered appropriately. The ice cream was delicious and I wish there was a place like this closer to me!