← All stops

Temporarily closed

Google currently lists this counter as temporarily closed. We keep the entry up for the record — call ahead before you drive out.

Butterfield's Ice Cream

Dover-Foxcroft, ME • 4.7 (364 Google reviews)

Inside Butterfield's Ice Cream
Butterfield's Ice Cream photo from Google
Butterfield's Ice Cream photo from Google

The Story

The cheerful chime of the bell welcomes you into Butterfield's, a true retro parlor where time seems to slow down just a bit. Scoop after generous scoop of creamy ice cream promises a perfect sweet treat for any sunny afternoon. This delightful stop on Main Street feels like a warm hug, full of simple pleasures and happy memories waiting to be made.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Rachelle S

    • 2 months ago

    It’s not the same. I really wish the new owners cared. This place has been a staple for my family for over 30 years. They painted over the mural, that should tell you all you need to know. They also converted half of it to sell meat? A butcher and ice cream place sharing a building? No. It’s really sad this place went from a family staple to a glorified Rita’s. They don’t follow the old recipes that created this place, the ice cream is clearly different. Chocolate peanut butter? You’re getting chocolate. Period. No peanut butter. (Which also, the old recipe is ignored. This peanut butter tastes like Reese’s sauce, not the original recipe) I usually don’t leave long reviews like this but it’s so heartbreaking to see a place I loved for my entire life get sold to people who truly do not care about anything except money. Why did you buy this business if you had no plans on holding its standards?

  • Lauren Bippert

    • 4 months ago

    Delicious ice cream and great service! Even with a long line, the staff were nice and helpful, especially with us first timers! Wide selection of delicious ice cream and the best banana split I have ever had! Definitely a must try!

  • Robert G.

    • 4 months ago

    Been here twice while visiting Dover-Foxcroft. Good service. Good ice cream. If I was to do a small critique, the Moose Tracks needs more bits added into the ice cream mix. After having a 2 scoop sundae, it was mostly vanilla ice cream. Second, bigger portions. A large sundae was really not that "large". Just 2.5 scoops drizzled with hot fudge. I was hoping for something twice that size. Otherwise, I enjoyed my ice cream.

  • Miss Mariss

    • 9 years ago

    The best ice cream that we have ever had! SO GOOD!! The only problem is it's 4+ hours away from where we live & I crave it all the time!! The flavors are all so good, and I haven't had ice cream like this anywhere else!!