← All stops

Caliche's Frozen Custard

Alamogordo, NM • 4.6 (1554 Google reviews)

Inside Caliche's Frozen Custard
Caliche's Frozen Custard photo from Google
Caliche's Frozen Custard photo from Google

The Story

The neon glow of Caliche's instantly pulls you back to simpler times, a perfect roadside stop under the big New Mexico sky. Each creamy spoonful of their frozen custard, heaped with imaginative toppings, feels like a sweet, comforting hug from days gone by. It’s a cheerful haven where folks gather for smiles and treats, making every visit a little taste of Americana.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Camil Blackburn

    • 3 months ago

    Pay $30 for 3 drinks and can't even get it correctly extra strawberries, extra cream cheese, and this is what I got. The sandbox were even worse is just a big glob of ice cream with just sprinkled Oreos. I paid thirty dollars for this.You know what's going to the trash, literally to the trash. With all due respect, do not reply back to me because I have 0 interest in ever coming back. I am so tired of giving people money and paying for stuff and not getting simple things back. Oh, and the classic and sir. I got you can come back and we can make you a new one. Why should a customer have to get in their car? In a 100° weather, go back to get the correct thing. It doesn't make sense, why wasn't it correct? The first time so you because of you, you want me to get in my car waste my time. So you can correct something you did wrong. It makes no sense, it makes no sense. It is not hard. I didn't ask for difficult things. Strawberry cheesecake with extra strawberries and extra cheesecake sandbox with extra Oreos. No worm, sandbox, extra oreo no fudge. That's what I ordered $30. Oh, I got fudge in one of them when I asked for no fudge. And then they whipped it together. So it didn't look like there was fudge like it's just so sad.You cannot go anywhere anymore to get a simple snack or treat that cost an arm and Leg and still get the order wrong is not the first, it's not the second and it's not the third and that's all on me. And having faith and maybe 1 day, you can pay for something. And get what you paid for.

  • CP

    • 7 months ago

    Usually they have decent ice cream except for when I order a fudge brownie bliss and barely get any brownie or when I got a cone today. As I was eating and got to the cone, I noticed some paper inside. Apparently, whoever fixed my cone, left a cone inside of another cone. If I wasn't paying attention, I would've eaten some paper along with the ice cream!

  • jack vanlyssel

    • 5 months ago

    Amazing ice cream, classic diner styling. Must try if passing through!!! Green chile ice cream with candied chiles pictured below.

  • Vanessa

    • 7 months ago

    (yes I took a few bites before I realized the toppings didn't slide to the bottom, they just weren't there). This place used to be amazing. Ever since they doubled their prices, and reduced their employee pay from $15 per hour down to minimum wage despite the price increase and economy struggle, this place has gone to shit. Work ethic is garbage, they've become insanely stingy with their toppings. Paying $8 for a banana split should get me more than four little strawberries, and they never put cherries on their Sundays anymore. In this economy, it sucks worrying if I'm going to just waste money here. $8 is a lot now, it feels like $8 is more expensive now than it was 5 years ago. Greed is a killer, I hope another custard shop opens in town that we can take our business to, until then, I'm done with custard. Also: their email is pointless, they lie to you and give you an email to "make it right!!!" just to give you a place to complain to with no response. I tried contacting them some months back about an issue, no response for weeks. I called the main location in Cruces and they gave me attitude telling me to "just wait and they'll get back to you". This was almost a year ago, I never got a response. They don't care about us as customers, or their employees, and it shows.