Captain Cookie & the Milk Man

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

• 

  Alexsandra Ayala

  ★ 5 • 2 months ago

  Over this past weekend me and my bf stopped here for a sweet treat. We were greeted by a kind young lady. She was patient and answered all our questions without making us feel rushed. She also allowed us to sample any ice creams to pick the best pair for a cookie sandwich. It began to get pretty busy, so we asked why she was working alone on a Saturday night, she mentioned her coworker leaving her shift, although she remained patient and calm with all customers coming in it definitely is an unfortunate situation because she seemed like a hard working young lady.

• 

  Dexter Lane

  ★ 5 • a year ago

  The coolest ice cream place I’ve happened across in a while. The general manager was very nice and told us all about the business. Loved learning about the owners and the story. The other employee there was also extremely friendly! Ice cream and cookies were both delicious! Loved the super hero theme!

• 

  Naima Muminiy

  ★ 5 • 2 months ago

  I don’t know what was the sweeter treat, the cookies or Ruth! I scarcely write reviews, but my husband and I went in yesterday and we were both blown away by the amazing customer service and warmth of Ruth, so these 5 stars are for her more than anything. It’s clear that this particular Captain Cookie is reliant on her positive energy and hardworking nature. I hope the management here acknowledges and awards her appropriately for it, she’s definitely one in a million!

• 

  kat Santiago

  ★ 3 • 2 years ago

  Had chocolate chip ice cream sandwich and double chocolate ice cream sandwich. Service was good but lines was long. Guys working were nice. Some sitting area upstairs and additional seating in market. The day we went they were making more chocolate chip cookies so it was a 20 min wait. They were also not making shakes that day. It's a busy location. In walking distance from where we were staying.