Coastal Creamery
Portland, ME • 4.6 (193 Google reviews)
The Story
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
M D (MountainDrew561)
• 3 months ago
The ice cream itself was excellent.. easily some of the best we had on our entire Maine trip, and we waited in line for about an hour and a half at another ice cream spot in Wells, so we definitely did our research. The Coffee Oreo was fantastic, and the Fluffernutter was just as good. From a food perspective, this is absolutely five-star ice cream. Where the experience fell a little short was the service and flexibility. They would not allow us to sample any flavors at all. I completely understand limiting samples, especially when there’s a line, but outright refusing any sample feels a little excessive for an ice cream shop. We also asked to add a topping to a cone and were told they wouldn’t do it because the toppings tend to fall off. They did offer to put the topping in a small cup on the side, which was a perfectly reasonable alternative, but having two requests met with an immediate “no” in such a short period of time definitely took away from the experience. I can understand the business side of it. They’re probably trying to keep the line moving, serve more customers efficiently, and avoid M&Ms and other toppings ending up all over the floor. But there has to be a better way to accomplish that without making the customer experience feel so restrictive. Overall, I’m giving Coastal Creamery four stars. The ice cream is legitimately excellent and absolutely worth getting, but the service policies could use a little more flexibility and hospitality.
Ciera Bass
• a month ago
amazing homemade maine ice cream! they have plenty of normal and odd flavors we were able to sample. i enjoyed the cider flavor with mixed in snickerdoodles immensely. friendly staff and they get you in and out fast. their single scoop is pretty big as well. warning: not accessible without steps or stairs and they don’t have indoor seating or bathrooms
Gunish Kaur Gujral
• 2 months ago
Excellent flavors and a great variety of options! There was a long line when we arrived, but it moved quickly and we got our turn sooner than expected. Everything was delicious, and the selection made it hard to choose just one. Definitely worth a visit if you’re in Portland!
Travis McDougall
• 5 months ago
This was a sweet surprise on a hot day in Portland. We were here as a port stop from our cruise ship and were unsure of what we wanted to do for the day. We went for a walk and found this fantastic Ice cream shop. Not far from the cruise port this amazing ice cream shop delivered in every way. Lots of the toppings with a fantastic Ice cream base. 2 scoops for a reasonable price and we were very pleased . We enjoyed every spoonful and reccomend to all walking through.