Colonia Dairy Maid
Colonia, NJ • 4.6 (1600 Google reviews)
The Story
Down-to-earth ice cream shop featuring familiar flavors & toppings, plus sherbet.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Manisha Sabat
• 4 months ago
This is one of the best ice-cream place. We ordered different flavors and totally loved all the flavors. They are busy but the line goes pretty fast. I highly recommend this place.
Patricia Jeskie
• 3 months ago
Colonia Dairy Maid never disappoints! The ice cream is always fresh, creamy, and delicious, with so many flavors to choose from. The portions are generous, the prices are reasonable, and the staff is always friendly and welcoming. Even when there’s a line, it’s worth the wait because the service is efficient and the quality is consistently excellent. This is one of my favorite local spots for ice cream, and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for a sweet treat!
Mitali Singh
• a year ago
They consistently have some of the best ice cream/sorbet in the area. The portions are very generous, but keep in mind that they’re a cash-only establishment. In the summer, there’s usually a line out the door, but during off season, you can go in and out quickly. They have an ATM inside and benches outside for seating. My go to flavor is coffee chip (not overly sweet with thick dark chocolate shards; sooo good). Some honorable flavor mentions: chocolate covered strawberry (this is a seasonal flavor I had around February which I beg them to make a permanent flavor because it’s PERFECT); cookies and cream, SpongeBob, devil’s food cake, and lemon Italian ice.
Luekisha Cook
• 3 weeks ago
No sign on the door or window stating it’s cash only. Ordered two medium cups of ice cream for my daughters, went to pay as they were already made and was told it’s CASH ONLY. Left the ice cream on the counter and walked out. Went down the street to carvel where we can use cards and tap to pay.