Temporarily closed
Google currently lists this counter as temporarily closed. We keep the entry up for the record — call ahead before you drive out.
Cowboy Creamery 'Western-style®' Super Premium Ice Cream
Sheridan, WY • 4.7 (154 Google reviews)
The Story
Stepping into Cowboy Creamery felt like a friendly hug from the past, with its bright retro parlor inviting you to slow down and savor the moment. The rich, super premium ice cream, handcrafted in classic Western style, tasted like pure Wyoming sunshine and happy memories in every scoop. It’s the kind of delightful stop that makes any drive through Sheridan feel a little sweeter and a whole lot more charming.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Beth
• 4 months ago
Very cool flavors! Way over priced. One scoop (half & half flavors) and a tip was nearly $10. No sample tastes. Red bean coffee flavor was icy. Yellowstone with banana flavor did not taste like fresh bananas, perhaps it included banana chips? Ice cream was creamy.
Ryan Burr
• 3 months ago
Some of the best ice cream we've ever tasted. We visit Sheridan every few years and always go out of our way to get this ice cream. We just stopped and picked up 17 pints for a family reunion ice cream tasting. The cinnamon was far tastier than I think anybody expected; it was like a creamy red hot. All the flavors were amazing. That said, the one with jalapeño was only liked by a handful of people, but those people loved it. As others have already said, the owner sells the old west cowboy theme really well and it is a fun place to visit.
Jenna H
• a week ago
Here on a trip, and found some of the best ice cream I’ve tasted in years. The ingredients are all fresh and real. The owner makes everything from scratch. We tried the prickly pear (huckleberry and pear), the ricotta and sage swirl in lemon cream and the chocolate with fudge and peanut butter swirl. AMAZING. We are making a trip back to buy some more before we leave town. Editing to update: it’s been months and we still talk about this ice cream. Hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever tasted in my life. As my sister would put it (she’s moving there soon) “if they ever close I’m moving out of Sheridan.”
Tony Russo
• a year ago
This place is absolutely worth stopping for We pulled over at random and the ice cream was fantastic. Since we were in a group, I got to taste a bunch of different flavors, everyone insisted that theirs was the best. The lemon ice cream was transcendent. 15 hands was a crowd favorite and Appaloosa (molasses cream with fudge pieces and white chocolate also was popular. I loved the coffee ice cream which had a coffee bitterness and richness that’s rare. Point is, you really can’t go wrong here.