Danzeisen Dairy - Creamery Store - Payson
Payson, AZ • ★ 4.7 (659 Google reviews)
The Story
Stepping into Danzeisen Dairy's Creamery feels like a sweet trip back in time, where the cheerful hum of conversation mixes with the inviting scent of fresh-baked cones. The vibrant, retro parlor welcomes you with a cozy embrace, making every scoop of rich, creamy ice cream a pure delight. From classic milkshakes to frosted treats, each indulgence offers a taste of simple, honest-to-goodness joy that brightens any Payson day.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
T Stoey
★ 5 • 6 months ago
Stopped in for dessert while in town and so glad we did! Wow, absolutely delicious! They have a great selection of flavors, toppings/mix-ins, and dessert options. We tried their Smores Stack Shake and whoa, it's loaded! Also tried a chocolate milkshake. Couldn't recommend the shake more - 10 out of 10! Plenty of seating inside. They have pre-made take away options too. We now have a go to spot of ice cream when in Payson!
Thu Hoang
★ 4 • 2 weeks ago
Great ice cream! But I would skip the shakes. There are lots of reviews commenting on how the shakes are amazing here... Maybe I had a fluke, but the shake I got was essentially milk. They barely put any ice cream in it. I expect shakes to be thick but it really did feel like I was drinking a cup of milk. It was also a coffee shake but the coffee was very very subtle. If I didn't know it was a "coffee shake", I would have thought it was vanilla milk. The ice cream was really good though! The place was extremely lively and the staff were very nice. Overall a super nice place that I would recommend people try the ice cream
Cayla Padberg
★ 5 • 11 months ago
Been meaning to try this place for ages but its always Sunday's when I'm near! (They're closed Sundays) Finally here on a Monday and so glad I made it in! Jordan was working the counter and he was patient with my questions and helpful with suggestions. I got a vanilla shake with salted caramel swirl and it tasted so fresh and delicious best shake I've ever had! And I love that they have thicker straws so I'm not fighting to take a drink. They also had a great variety of lemon/limeade and other beverages you can take home.
Chantel Vasquez
★ 5 • a month ago
Took my neighbor up to Payson for her 95th birthday and stopped in for ice cream. All 3 girls were friendly and smiley, but Lizzy went out of her way to greet, serve, and suggest an amazing creation just for her, and brought it out with a sparklers for a candle. She truly made her feel special and she has told everyone all week that it was the best ice cream she's ever had. Thanks Lizzy for helping make her day amazing! My salted caramel milkshake was fantastic as well!
