Diamonds Ice Cream
Columbus • ★ 4.6 (510 Google reviews)
The Story
This fantastic spot offers a wide variety of authentic Mexican ice creams, popsicles, and custom fruit treats that are surprisingly vibrant and delicious. Their paletas are a must-try, with options like orange & cream or kiwi strawberry. You'll want to come back to try more of their extensive selection, including the fruity pebbles or bubblegum paletas.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Ramesh Basina
★ 5
A hidden gem for authentic treats! Our family’s first time here and it certainly won't be our last. They have a fantastic variety of authentic Mexican ice creams, popsicles, and custom fruit treats that completely surprised us with how vibrant and delicious they are. The service was top-notch—very welcoming and helpful. Love the fun, colorful interior decor too! Highly recommend checking this place out.
Dain Vossar (Galaxy Wanderer)
★ 5
Stopped in at Diamonds for some sweet refreshment, and the Force was definitely with these popsicles. I ordered an Orange & Cream and a Kiwi Strawberry—both were out-of-this-galaxy good. The orange was creamy, smooth, and nostalgic, while the kiwi strawberry had bright, fresh flavors with real fruit slices that made it feel extra special. 🍊🍓🥝 The staff were friendly, helpful, and patient while I browsed the many flavors of paletas and ice creams. With so many choices (everything from classics to adventurous picks like avocado and rice pudding), there’s definitely something here for every P
Audie Doodah
★ 5
Came here to try their paletas. I got the fruity pebbles and kiwi strawberry mango paletas. They have a very large selection of items to choose from that'll make you want to come again to try more of their items. I will be coming back to try their elote and bubblegum paletas. Pricing is fair, with paletas being $3.99 a piece and scoops being $5. Staff was nice and helpful, it wasn't very busy but the dining room was organized and clean. Checkout was also simple. I reccomend coming here if you want a quick, indulgent little snack, or if you want to try something new. EDIT : I've seen some peopl
Babul Ali
★ 5
Wow. Absolutely amazing place. Stumbled across this place as we were driving past it. We ordered the Popsicles and they tasted divine. We also ordered a fruit dessert (forgot the name but it's in the picture). The service was exceptional, the staff were friendly, the fruit dessert was made in front of us with so much care.