Temporarily closed
Google currently lists this counter as temporarily closed. We keep the entry up for the record — call ahead before you drive out.
Door County Ice Cream Factory & Sandwich Shoppe
Sister Bay, WI • 4.7 (1308 Google reviews)
The Story
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Andrew Hayman
• 2 months ago
Cute place on the north side of Sister Bay. I ranked it on the quality of my $11 chocolate malted which was not wonderful. Bear in mind, I was comparing it to Wilson's, who make what I believe is in my Top 5 all time for chocolate shakes/malted. Nice indoor and Outdoor seating area...good for dogs. Friendly staff. My daughter loved the ice cream sandwich offering. If you have more than 3 days in Door Cty, definitely worth a visit.
Jennifer Halama
• a month ago
My spouse wanted a sandwich for lunch so we found ourselves here. I wouldn't say that we'll be back again after our visit. He ordered the grilled ham and cheese sandwich with chips. I had a half sandwich with side salad. Upgraded to the tomato and mozzarella salad which was supposed to have balsamic vinaigrette on it - I feel this was totally missed. We took our meal to go so there was no chance for correction. My half sandwich was ok, nothing spectacular. With all of the choices in Door Co. I wouldn't go out of my way.
KEN
• 3 months ago
Picture this: it’s a cozy, rainy afternoon. The streets are bustling with tourists trying to avoid the rain, and most restaurants are packed to the brim. You’re not quite sure where to go for something quick and relaxing. That’s when we stumbled upon this charming little spot—a delightful ice cream sandwich and pizza shop that feels just like an old-fashioned parlor. We walked right in, ordered with ease, and before we knew it, our food was waiting for us. The service was warm and welcoming, and the food? Absolutely fresh and delicious. Honestly, it was the fastest we’ve ever been served pizza, and it made the whole rainy day feel bright and comforting.
K
• 6 months ago
Nice clean place Happy staff. I enjoyed the ham sandwich on wheat since it tasted good and fresh. Yummy Door County Cherry ice cream and other flavors. I should have had the other sandwich they recommended and just taking some home. A relative enjoyed their turkey sub and the waffle cone with Door County Cherry ice cream . Always next time to try more. 😊👍👍