Fairway Creamery
Kansas City, MO • 4.6 (36 Google reviews)
The Story
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Pooja Patel
• in the last week
Stopped by on a whim on a Saturday night. Very happy that we did. They had about 8 options of ice cream but all the ones we tried were delicious. They had some nice seasonal options. The strawberry and German chocolate were delicious. Very creamy and good flavor profiles. They also have pints of other flavors for sale too along with ice cream sandwiches. The 2 girls working were a good vibe and very friendly too! It’s pretty small on the inside with not a ton of seating. Overall an excellent place to stop by for dessert after dinner in any of the many great restaurants in the 1 block radius. Also they are anti-ICE and that is simply the cherry on top.
jaydan perez
• 5 months ago
The ice cream was delicious , and the customer service stood out. Both workers were welcoming and helped us pick flavors. The shop was clean and had a great atmosphere. Highly recommend!
Carter Taylor
• 4 months ago
I want to preface this by saying that my review is not a result of the customer service provided by the kids who were working when I went. They were kind, polite, and professional throughout the entire experience. With that out of the way, the critiques I have to offer as a true ice cream lover and someone who was very excited to come here are as follows: The non dairy ice cream selection and experience. The options were two sorbets and a frankly wild jalepeño flavor. I don’t want to put down anyone’s creativity, but I want to express that, as someone who cannot actually have dairy, that doesn’t mean that I don’t want to have the same experience as everyone else. Being vegan doesn’t necessarily mean that I have super out there tastes, and having an option that is more basic like the vegan chocolate or vanilla that the other location has had in the past would make a big difference. That would give the chance to choose to be adventurous, rather than having that be something of a default. I did give the sorbet a try, but even then it was a somewhat lackluster experience since it isn’t something from a case, it had to be purchased as a premade half pint (but if you were expecting that half pint to be full, please note that it is not a half pint. It is a single scoop in the container). That’s really sad when you wanted to have an ice cream cone with your friends, though thankfully the staff were very kind and gave me a cone to put on the top. The sorbet wasn’t my favorite, due to the texture, and my friends who tried it were of the same opinion. I want to give credit for having any non dairy options at all, but overwhelmingly that has become the standard over the past several years, which I’m grateful for, and I think it is fair to ask for better experiences and thoughtful decisions in terms of offerings. My friends who went with me had regular sundaes, and while they also expressed repeatedly that they had their own disappointments with it, I won’t speak further on their experiences since I don’t believe that’s fair if I wasn’t able to judge it for myself. Overall, I’m hoping that after some more time for finding their footing in the neighborhood that I will be able to revisit this review and update it to reflect that this was simply a matter of growing pains.
Ronan Blackridge
• 6 months ago
Fairway Creamery is the kind of ice cream shop that turns a simple dessert stop into a memorable experience. From the moment you walk in, the atmosphere feels cheerful and welcoming, with a tempting display of flavors that makes it hard to choose just one. Everything looks fresh, and you can tell a lot of care goes into every scoop. The ice cream itself is outstanding. Each flavor is rich, creamy, and full of authentic taste. The vanilla is smooth and classic, the chocolate is deep and indulgent, and the seasonal flavors offer something unique and exciting. Whether you prefer traditional favorites or adventurous combinations, Fairway Creamery has something for everyone. The texture is perfectly creamy, and every bite tastes like it was made with high-quality ingredients. What makes Fairway Creamery even better is the excellent customer service. The staff is friendly, patient, and always happy to offer recommendations or samples to help you decide. Their enthusiasm adds to the fun and makes the visit even more enjoyable. The shop is clean, bright, and family-friendly, making it a great place to visit with kids, friends, or anyone with a sweet tooth. Portions are generous, and the prices are very reasonable for the quality you receive. Fairway Creamery delivers delicious ice cream, welcoming service, and a wonderful overall experience. It’s a place worth visiting again and again whenever you’re craving a truly satisfying frozen treat.