← All stops

Fenwick Ice Co.

Selbyville, DE • ★ 4.9 (199 Google reviews)

Inside Fenwick Ice Co.
Fenwick Ice Co. photo from Google
Fenwick Ice Co. photo from Google

The Story

The screen door creaks a friendly welcome at Fenwick Ice Co., beckoning you into a world where checkered floors and the sweet scent of sugar transport you back to simpler times. Here, generous scoops of velvety ice cream and frothy milkshakes promise a pure taste of yesteryear, perfectly enjoyed under the glow of nostalgic neon signs. It’s a delightful pause on Lighthouse Road, where every treat feels like a little piece of small-town summer.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Diana Fogg

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    Great spot! Love the color changing spoon and the super large size when it was only charged for a medium! Will be back to try more flavors cause tropical was amazing!

  • Lucid Ann

    ★ 5 • 2 weeks ago

    We went here 3 nights out of 5 of our vacation! The staff was great. Ice flavors were the best I've ever had. They didnt give me that tickle in my throat other places do. Met Cheryl the owner and she was so kind and welcoming! We would HIGHLY recommend!

  • Johanna Devon

    ★ 5 • 2 weeks ago

    Local faborite. If you are just visiting, this a great place to check out. Off the beach on Route 54. Easy to get to. Enough parking. The kids behind the counter work well together. The shaved ice has so many flavors. Spend some time playing the yard games. They do need so more seating.

  • AnnMarie Potts

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    Amazing! Had lime ice with vanilla soft serve and snocap…rode past here the past couple years that we’ve come down and never got to stop. First time this year and we will definitely be back!