Fielder's Choice Ice Cream
Manchester, ME • ★ 4.7 (1535 Google reviews)
The Story
Stepping into Fielder's Choice is like a sweet trip back in time, with its cheerful retro charm and friendly chatter filling the air. The creamy scoops piled high offer a perfect summer escape, each bite a taste of simple, honest-to-goodness joy. It's the kind of place where memories are made, alongside the delicious cool treat in your hand.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Daniela Sanchez
★ 3 • a month ago
I visited on Sunday and really enjoyed my ice cream—it was delicious, and the portions were very generous. However, as I was finishing it, I found a hair in my ice cream. I would recommend being more careful with food preparation and hygiene to help prevent this from happening in the future.
Dawn Dickson
★ 2 • a month ago
Rather disappointed with the ice cream. I ordered an M&M’s hard serve and the vanilla ice cream was tasteless with very few bits of M&M’s. Have had much better ice cream at other places.
Tonia Taylor
★ 4 • 2 years ago
There was about fifty customers either eating at picnic tables, in line ordering or eating at their cars but it was a hot and busy night for them. For as busy as they were, service was fast and correct. They have picnic tables to eat at, unfortunately this isn't a place you can eat inside at but there's a lot of picnic tables around the front of the building. This is a cash only business they don't accept anything except cash but they have an atm. They had quite a few staff on tonight which was good because it was really busy. There's tons of parking so you should always be able to find a spot. The location is easy to find, it's right on the main drag of western avenue. Prices are decent and cheaper then dairy queen. They are open seasonally until nine at night. I got the black raspberry home run, my husband got the peanut butter dug out and our friend got the mint with oreos home run. Big portions for under twenty bucks. We were all happy with the ice cream and service. Thank-You! Overall, 4 stars!
Linda Littlefield
★ 5 • 3 years ago
Wow. We had a small ice cream in a waffle cone. The portions are huge. The flavors are delicious. They do have picnic tables set up around the shop. They only take cash but have an ATM available in front of the shop. We had butter pecan... so many pecans. Yum. Also, a coffee oreo. There are so many oreos, so yummy. It's always fun to try different flavors.
