← All stops

Fielder's Choice

Old Orchard Beach, ME • 4.7 (1400 Google reviews)

Inside Fielder's Choice
Fielder's Choice photo from Google
Fielder's Choice photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Eric

    • 4 months ago

    Wow!!! We are so glad that we found this place. Ice cream was wonderful and plentiful. We ordered a triple soft serve / chocolate and black cherry and it must have been close to a half gallon for $5. Next time, we are going to have less for dinner and bigger sundaes! Great staff!!! Picnic tables near parking lot for you to enjoy the tasty treat.

  • Andrea Labonte

    • a month ago

    If you want really good ice cream then try these guys the menu was huge couldn’t decide what I really wanted. I got the dugout with butterfinger ice cream, peanut sauce, hot fudge, Reese’s peanut butter cups and whipped cream so good and my partner got vanilla chocolate chip ice cream with graham cracker broken up into it and chocolate and marshmallow sauce.

  • ScarletteLane

    • 2 months ago

    I’ll make this short and sweet (like ice cream). Fielders choice is a must try. All the ice cream is homemade. Hard and soft serve are both amazing. They are generous with their scoops and staff are all very friendly. You can get ice cream in the drive through. Don’t let the line deter you, it goes pretty fast & it’s worth it. Listen to me when I tell you, you gotta try it!

  • Sharon Parkhurst

    • 3 months ago

    We stop here every year (sometimes more than once lol)! Saturday when we were here I got my Muddy Cleat (add heath bar) made with Strawberry Sorbet (dairy free yaaaaayyy) & it was absolutely amazing!! You guys NEVER disappoint!