Forever Sweet Creamery
Paducah, KY • ★ 4.9 (108 Google reviews)
The Story
The aroma of sweet vanilla and chocolate dances in the air the moment you step inside, a delightful throwback to simpler, happier times. Swirling sundaes and frosty malts, piled high with cheerful toppings, promise a taste of pure joy in this charming, old-fashioned haven. It’s the perfect cozy stop for a scoop of happiness, where every treat feels like a comforting hug from days gone by.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Tim Cochran: Wader Yoga
★ 5 • 4 months ago
Delicious ice cream made in-house. Great selection of flavors. Fantastic customer service!!!
Tammy Weatherby
★ 4 • 11 months ago
It was a bit difficult to find using Google maps. I think its because it's trying to take you to the alley. Their entrance is on the main street. The ice cream was good, nothing amazing...lol I consider myself an ice cream connoisseur. We had the blueberry cheesecake and the raspberry almond cake. The blueberries were frozen and kinda freezer burned because of water in them. You could taste the cheesecake which was nice. The raspberry almond cake was ok, the almond cake didn't really stand out. The staff were nice and helpful. They do limit you to 2 samples. They also charge a fee for using a credit card, which is okay, but would be nice if they mention that. It looks as though they also charge tax on the credit card fee, which I believe is not okay. Definitely a unique ice cream shop, they also make pizza which is a bit odd. There is limited parking on the street and some lots within walking distance.
Katie Texas
★ 5 • 3 years ago
ICE CREAM NACHOS!!!! With home made waffle chips. 😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋 The place was cute to perfection with the best staff. I believe I got to speak with the owner. This place has every charm an ice cream shop should have. The ice creams are very unique in flavor. All so delicious! We were sent on our way with delicious warm coffees for the walk back to our bnb. Thank you so much for making our trip such a memorable one. And with a desert we will never forget. But will definitely try to mimic, knowing we will fail. Can’t wait to come back to Peducah! Also would like to add I bought a cinnamon role in a cup with icing and oh my good gracious…. Who ever is baking that has a gift from above.
Rafe Bar
★ 5 • 2 years ago
We were in town for the 2024 eclipse, and what an awesome way to end the eclipse by having some delicious ice cream. They even have old school candy, it was pretty nostalgic to see all the different kinds they had, most of which I thought were discontinued, or maybe just hard to find but were from my childhood.
