← All stops

Forget me not soda shoppe

Middleburgh, NY • 4.8 (39 Google reviews)

Inside Forget me not soda shoppe
Forget me not soda shoppe photo from Google
Forget me not soda shoppe photo from Google
Forget me not soda shoppe photo from Google

The Story

Middleburgh's Railroad Avenue hides a tiny fountain done up in checkerboard and chrome, where the owners mix phosphates and floats for hikers coming off the Long Path. Small town, big sundaes.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Scott Pomerico

    • 2 months ago

    So much fun for a little shop. Owner and staff are super friendly and also very accommodating for someone with nut allergies. Lisa’s coffee shake was great. We also got a root beer float aand straws banana smoothie. Highly recommend if you’re in the area to visit Howe Caverns or on the way to Cooperstown from NYC.

  • Agostino Sinapi

    • 4 months ago

    Awesome find on our way home from Cooperstown! The place brings you into a time capsule. Great for kids and super for treats. The dirty sodas on the menu and milkshakes make this a multi-visit type place. Highly recommend the buffalo wrap. Flavorful, light and textured. I really enjoyed it. The boys scarfed down the dogs. Less eating, more like inhaling. The owner was remarkably friendly and kind. Let's just hope he doesn't stick his hand in a hedge trimmer again. 😂. (Sorry, I had to add that in, great story) There was another person cooking and helping. She was super fast and friendly. Overall, amazing find! Highly recommend.

  • Naman Bagga

    • a year ago

    We visited this shop last Friday. The store owner is Lisa, very warm and welcoming with her voice. She is friendly and answers all the questions with patience. It was already closed bcz we were 5 mins late. But she let us come in, opened store for us, gave tour of her classic shop, which had 90s theme. Felt like we are in 90s. She also has a classic game room for kids. Kids love the classic candies they have, reminded me of my childhood. Thanks Lisa for making our evening hour in downtown worth memorable.

  • Michael Oakes

    • 3 months ago

    This place was amazing! Absolutely perfect! The atmosphere was amazing, and reminded me alot of Archie, and those classic Americana malt shops. No other words, just beautiful! I think I'm in love with the place.