Frosty’s Griddle and Shake
St Simons Island, GA • ★ 4.2 (819 Google reviews)
The Story
Hamburger Restaurant in St Simons Island, rated 4.2 by locals.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Alison Rickert
★ 5 • a month ago
Genuinely the best chili cheese fries I’ve ever had. The chicken strips are also phenomenal. Do yourself a favor and get the brownie sundae. One of our new favorite spots on the island! It’s worth the wait when it’s busy and the staff are always kind!
Onna Koehn
★ 5 • 3 months ago
With a classic diner feel and solid desert menu, what else do you need on the island? Not actually a huge fan of ice-cream, but when at the beach and in the heat it sure was refreshing!
Thomas Ferland
★ 5 • 2 months ago
My grandmother and I had a wonderful experience at Frosted on St. Simons. The food and service were excellent, but what really stood out was the kindness of the staff. A group of college-aged employees noticed that my grandmother needed a little extra help and went out of their way to assist her. They patiently walked her to our car and made sure she got there safely. Their genuine care, respect, and willingness to help meant so much to our family. It’s rare to see such outstanding customer service and compassion. We will definitely be back and highly recommend Frosted to others!
Greg Gourley
★ 5 • 9 months ago
A Perfect Old-School Burger Spot Frosty’s on St. Simons Island has become one of my favorite places to grab lunch, especially on Sundays. It has that classic 70s–80s hamburger-joint feel—nothing fancy, just good food, good music from the local radio station, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes you want to come back. The Frosty Deluxe Burger is my go-to. It’s consistently delicious, cooked just right, and genuinely one of the best burgers around. Their crispy crinkle-cut fries are the perfect match—hot, crunchy, and exactly what you want next to a great burger. And the shakes? Outstanding. Thick, smooth, and always made well. The service is another huge reason I love Frosty’s. There’s a lady who often works the counter on Sundays—unfortunately I don’t know her name—but she is always incredibly kind and welcoming. She sets the tone for the whole place. Every visit, the service has been fast, friendly, and consistently great. If you’re looking for a classic, no-nonsense burger place with great food, great people, and a nostalgic vibe, Frosty’s is exactly where you want to be. Highly recommended!
