← All stops

Gilles Frozen Custard

Milwaukee, WI • 4.5 (2488 Google reviews)

Inside Gilles Frozen Custard
Gilles Frozen Custard photo from Google
Gilles Frozen Custard photo from Google

The Story

A sweet aroma of vanilla and cherry floats on the breeze as you pull into the parking lot of that timeless Milwaukee gem. Inside, the vibrant retro parlor hums with happy chatter, a comforting backdrop to families and friends enjoying an evening out. Each spoonful of their velvety frozen custard and every sip of a thick, frosty shake feels like a taste of pure Americana.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Mitch W

    • a month ago

    Stopped at Gillies since it's such an iconic spot, and it definitely has that classic custard stand feel. Custard itself was alright, nothing crazy but decent. Staff didn't seem too friendly though, service felt a bit cold. Still glad I stopped by for the experience.

  • 1badruckus

    • 5 months ago

    I grew up in New Berlin not knowing this place existed. I was torn between a burger and the sloppy Joe so I ordered both. The sloppy Joe was very good and reminded me of my mothers’. The burger was decent also. I washed it down with a root beer. I would stop again to try the custard as I left no room.

  • Joe Bahr

    • 3 months ago

    Burger was ok, chocolate shake was good. I will return. A must visit place while in Milwaukee.

  • Justin McBrearty

    • a year ago

    Gilles is Milwaukee’s oldest frozen custard shop, so I was excited to finally stop in again during a custard run with my partner. We visited on a Friday night and the flavor of the day was lemon. The neon sign lit up nicely as we pulled in, and there was plenty of parking. It was busy, but the line moved quickly, and the staff at the counter were friendly and welcoming. We ordered a scoop of the lemon custard along with their specialty that month, curly fries. Unfortunately, both were disappointing. The custard tasted watery and lacked the dense, creamy texture you expect from frozen custard. It may have been a bad batch, but it didn’t compare well to other places. The curly fries were also bland, without the seasoned coating you’d expect from curly fries like Arby’s. Pricing is on the higher side. A three-scoop dish at Gilles costs $7.25, compared to $6.00 at Kopp’s and $4.15 at Oscar’s. With the custard’s texture off and the fries underwhelming, it felt like poor value for the price. That said, service was fast and friendly, and I’d be open to giving Gilles another try. With its long history, I want to believe this visit was just an off night.