Good Ol' Wishy's
Croghan • ★ 4.8 (175 Google reviews)
The Story
Step into this unique establishment and be transported to a bygone era with its antique decor and a welcoming, friendly atmosphere. Good Ol' Wishy's offers a wide array of flavors for both traditional and soft-serve ice cream, known for its generous servings. It's a beloved local stop, especially for those seeking that perfect scoop and a dose of community charm.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Smarter Life
★ 5
Nestled in the heart of Croghan, New York, Good Ol' Wishy's is a delightful throwback to the days of old-fashioned soda fountains and country stores. This charming establishment seamlessly combines the nostalgia of a bygone era with the comforts of a contemporary cafe, making it a unique and inviting destination for locals and visitors alike. Upon arriving at Good Ol' Wishy's, the first thing that catches your eye is the comfortable seating area out front. Adorned with umbrellas for shade, it provides a welcoming spot to relax and soak in the small-town atmosphere. The rustic charm extends be
Thanh Spitale
★ 5
Always great and friendly service here. Love the old vibe you get from all the antiques. Plenty of flavors to choose from as well as soft serve.
Gordon Ingalls
★ 5
Great spot. Love stopping in while in town. Generous servings and friendly staff as well.
Elijah Negron-Harrison
★ 5
One day I'm going back up just to get some wishys, don't know if the name was just wishys back then but after every baseball game my brother went to, we would go here, and I'll say one thing it's better than all the ice cream I've ever tasted before. So good I still have memories of it. 💕