← All stops

Graeter's Ice Cream

Westerville, OH • ★ 4.6 (366 Google reviews)

Inside Graeter's Ice Cream
Graeter's Ice Cream photo from Google
Graeter's Ice Cream photo from Google

The Story

Stepping into Graeter's in Westerville felt like a sweet trip back in time, with laughter echoing off the charming retro decor and the delightful scent of waffle cones filling the air. Each generous, small-batch scoop was a creamy dream, a perfect treat after a leisurely stroll through town. Families gathered, savoring signature sundaes and frosty drinks, making memories under the warm glow of a classic American ice cream parlor.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Mark Hamilton

    ★ 5 • 4 weeks ago

    They have the best ice-cream. I had the Blueberry pie this time. It was awesome. My go to is lemmon Meringue. They put Candied Lemon on top of it. Love it!

  • Siham J

    ★ 5 • a year ago

    Love this place: welcoming staff and quick service popular place 🍦✨ Sweet from creamy French Pot ice cream (Butter Pecan = my fave 😍) to chocolates & candies, there’s something for everyone. See pics 🐶💖 Mark your calendars—Dogs’ Night Out every first Thursday of the month. Next September 4 from 6–9 pm! Pups get a frozen treat while you enjoy yours. Who’s bringing their dog? 🐾🍫

  • Bill Johnson

    ★ 5 • 5 months ago

    Having a coffee milkshake is one of my little life indulgences. And I dearly love the ones I can get at Graeters. Great service, friendly staff. When downtown is busy parking can be a bear. Walking through downtown Westerville is always a pleasure.

  • MRBARBQ 1

    ★ 4 • 3 years ago

    Decided to drop in to check out the Westerville Graeter’s . I was greeted by Jaylin, he’s been working there for around 3 years. I ordered the Love Boat Sundae with Black Raspberry chip and Black Cherry chip. Both had great flavor and huge chunks of chocolate mixed in. The only thing wrong was the little candy hearts were harder than a rock. Time for a fresh batch, otherwise a great experience.