Handel's Homemade Ice Cream
Noblesville, IN • 4.6 (411 Google reviews)
The Story
Long-standing ice cream parlor offering many flavors of ice cream & sorbet, plus sundaes & shakes.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Benjamin Huang
• 5 months ago
Petition to make Raspberry Sheet Cake 🍰, Blueberry Cobbler 🫐, French Silk Pie 🥧, and Knot Your Average Dough 🍪 into permanent menu items, not just flavors of the month where you have no idea when they'll bring it back once the month is over. 😢🥹😭😭 I'm going to be so sad if any of these four flavors are taken off the menu! So sayeth the Level 7 Local Guide. Handel's Homemade Ice Cream is amazing! 🍨 Made fresh daily, on location, using the highest quality milk, fruits, and ingredients, they never skimp, and you can expect deliciousness every time. From the humble beginnings in 1945, where Alice Handel made ice cream at home using fresh milk and the fruits from her garden, Handel's has grown to become the definitive local ice cream shop! The texture is something to note. The ice cream strikes the perfect balance between rich and creamy on one hand, yet light at the same time. Very few ice cream shops ever strike this kind of balance. Cold Stone Creamery, for example, is way too rich, and you end up with a parched throat. At the same time, many ice creams that are light and icy lack substance to them. Enter Handel's, who strikes the perfect balance between these two! Recommendations: get the four scoop sampler. My go to combination is as follows: 1) Cake batter 🎂; 2) Raspberry Sheet Cake 🍰; 3) Blueberry Cobbler 🫐; and 4) French Silk Pie. 🍫 🥧 This way, no matter how you combine it, you're either eating cake with berries 🫐, or chocolate cake! 🍫 An honorable mention is Knot Your Average Dough. Chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream swirled with pretzel dough!! 🥨 The pie crust for French Silk Pie and the pretzel dough for Knot Your Average Dough has the best combination of textures too! Somehow striking the right balance between soft and chewy, yet it still has that crunch to it at the same time! All while frozen too! Local rankings for ice cream shops in the Indianapolis area: 1) Handel's Homemade Ice Cream; 2) Kilwins; 3) Bruster's Real Ice Cream; and 4) Graeter's Ice Cream. Handel's Homemade Ice Cream: serving smiles and fond memories since 1945. An ice cream shop you can trust.
Patsy U.
• a month ago
Handles Ice Cream in Noblesville, Indiana, unfortunately fell short of expectations during my recent visit. While I anticipated a long wait—common at this location—the real disappointment came from the service. I ordered a banana split, along with two small waffle cones: one with cheesecake Biscoff and the other with raspberry chocolate chunk. To my dismay, the strawberry in my banana split turned out to be a strawberry sherbet, which was not what I was expecting. The cherry topping was excessively loaded, overshadowing the other flavors, and the pineapple and strawberry toppings didn’t help either as the excessive amounts overwhelmed the ice cream. More frustrating was my husband’s order. He received chocolate chunk instead of raspberry chocolate chunk, completely missing the raspberry flavor we were looking forward to. It seems there’s a need for better training for the staff, as our experience was marred by these mix-ups. I had hoped for a delightful treat, but instead, it felt like a real letdown.
Syeda Kashfia
• a month ago
Tried the Graham Station flavor at Handles and really enjoyed it! The flavor was creamy, rich, and had a delicious combination of sweet and crunchy textures. It was definitely a fun flavor to try and something different from the usual ice cream choices. The ice cream was fresh, smooth, and not overly sweet. I’d definitely try this flavor again!
Geo Mab
• a year ago
We loved this place a lot. Hansel’s Ice Cream is definitely the spot for great service and tasty treats. Whenever you’re around this part of town, the line of people waiting says it all—this place is a hit. They didn’t disappoint at all with their servings, and the salted caramel was our favorite among the many choices. We walked away happy and full.