Handel's Ice Cream
Greenwood, IN • 4.7 (1104 Google reviews)
The Story
Long-standing ice cream parlor offering many flavors of ice cream & sorbet, plus sundaes & shakes.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
JW Vance
• 2 weeks ago
Really neat place with some of the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Staff is friendly and the place is clean. My kids loved it. Try the s’mores 😎👍🏽
Lonnie Perry
• 3 months ago
Handel’s Ice Cream delivered exactly the kind of warm‑night treat that makes the whole visit feel worthwhile. We arrived on a busy evening when parking was tough and the line stretched well past the door, but once we found a spot and stepped into the queue, it moved quickly. The staff were working with real purpose, friendly, fast, and clearly proud of what they were serving, which made the experience feel welcoming even with the crowd. What sets Handel’s apart is the way they make their ice cream. Everything is produced fresh on‑site in small batches using a hand‑crafted method that goes back to the 1940s. They still rely on slow churning that keeps air out and flavor in, giving the ice cream a dense, velvety texture you can taste immediately. Real ingredients like cream, fruit, cookies, and nuts are folded in generously, and every scoop feels like something made with care rather than something mass‑produced. Their long list of flavors includes classics, seasonal specials, sundaes, hurricanes, pops, and thoughtful vegan options that stand on their own. I chose their version of Cookies‑n‑Creme, packed with cookie pieces and perfectly balanced in sweetness and creaminess. My wife enjoyed the vegan peanut butter, which was smooth, rich, and surprisingly indulgent for a dairy‑free option. Both were delicious and exactly what we needed on a warm night. Even with the crowds, Handel’s delivered a memorable experience. Friendly service, fresh small‑batch ice cream, and a huge variety of flavors make it easy to understand why people line up for it. It’s a place where tradition and craftsmanship come together, and it’s absolutely worth a visit whether you’re craving a classic scoop or exploring something new from their menu.
Mindy B.
• 3 weeks ago
I LOVE HANDEL’S!! They are the very best hands down!! My friend and I go every Sunday because we love it so much. I had apple today and it was yummy. They have a variety of flavors and a wide selection of what you can order (ie cones, bowls, samplers, hurricanes, etc) at very reasonable prices, too especially considering the serving they give you. My friend and I always get the 2 small waffle cones for $10. It’s a great deal because they give you 3 scoops!! They’re always staffed well so you get through the line quickly. The staff is always very welcoming and nice.
Caleb Rice
• a week ago
One of our favorite ice cream spots in Greenwood! We love the variety in flavors. The sampler dish is a fun option if you want to share for a date or with your family and friends. Parking is limited but the ice cream is amazing!