← All stops

Herrell's Ice Cream & Bakery

Northampton, MA • 4.5 (1085 Google reviews)

Inside Herrell's Ice Cream & Bakery
Herrell's Ice Cream & Bakery photo from Google
Herrell's Ice Cream & Bakery photo from Google

The Story

Longtime ice cream specialist with handcrafted flavors, plus homemade hot fudge & other toppings.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Michael Ammirata

    • 5 months ago

    One of the best Ice cream shops I've ever been to, easily top five. Excellent service, great selection of flavors, roomy and pleasant seating. My only complaint is that I was not able to tip the staff with my credit card. I don't often carry cash, so I this was disappointing.

  • Paige Coite

    • 5 months ago

    I feel personally offended, robbed, and taken advantage of. My boyfriend and I stopped here for some ice cream on our bike ride. We thought if we got kiddies it would be pretty cheap. When we ordered a kiddie she pointed to the cup it would go in and I genuinely thought it was a joke. It’s laughable. A kiddie (over $4 with tax) is 1 ounce of ice cream. That’s a sample size. That’s like divying up a pint of Ben and Jerry’s for 16 people. A SIXTEENTH OF A PINT OF ICE CREAM FOR OVER 4 dollars. And then if you want any toppings it’s minimum $1.50 up charge. Whipped cream is almost $2. I’m appalled, offended, upset. Small businesses need to go back to being wholesome small business instead of taking advantage of their customers. I will NEVERRR be returning. The ice cream was not nearly good enough to be charged such an egregious amount of money. RESPONSE: Excuse me, 2 ounces. That makes it better. Yes, costs are high....but not THAT high for 2 ounces of mediocre ice cream. The cost of that kiddie, is the cost of one gallon of gas. I don't care if the sizes have been the same, this was my first visit and that is absolutely irrelevant to the price. Unless you are saying that 45 years ago you charged over $4 for those 2 ounces. Is that what you are saying. Otherwise completely irrelevant and I would like to emphasize the ice cream was mediocre at best. Not worth my money and I hope all readers choose to go elsewhere, otherwise they will keep taking advantage.

  • Brian Lapis

    • 5 months ago

    Herrell’s! A pillar of Pioneer Valley culture! We are big fans of ordering pints and quarts to go. Call it in or order from the counter, do your other downtown business, and pick up when you head out of town! These pints and quarts are hand packed to order. We try not to do this on busy weekends. Service is always friendly! The first hour is free in the garage!

  • Howdydoo

    • 5 months ago

    Nice place but don’t recommend the vegan/non-dairy flavors. They’re watery and just barely edible. I ended up throwing it out. It’s nice that they are considering accessibility (nut-free etc) but not very effective if the result is unpleasant.