Hinlickity’s Ice Cream Parlor
Highlands, NJ • ★ 4.7 (145 Google reviews)

The Story
Stepping through the door at Hinlickity's, the scent of vanilla and sugar immediately wrapped around you, taking you back to simpler times. Red-and-white checkered floors and sparkling chrome stools invited folks to settle in for a spell, just like parlors of old. Each towering scoop, from classic chocolate to strawberry swirl, tasted like a little piece of summertime happiness right there on Bay Avenue.