← All stops

Hometown Creamery

Selbyville, DE • ★ 4.6 (40 Google reviews)

Inside Hometown Creamery
Hometown Creamery photo from Google
Hometown Creamery photo from Google

The Story

The classic checkerboard floor and spinning stools at Hometown Creamery instantly whisk you back to simpler times, filled with the sweetest nostalgia. Each scoop of their rich, handcrafted ice cream is a pure delight, melting creamy goodness on your tongue with every spoonful. It’s a perfect little corner of Americana, where laughter mingles with the clinking of spoons and the joy of a perfect frosty treat.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • George Schwendtner

    ★ 5 • 4 weeks ago

    Exceptional service! Everything was very clean, and we were warmly welcomed into the business even as they were closing for the day. The entire Property Tenders family team enjoyed a wonderful visit to Hometown Creamery on International Ice Cream Day and were treated to delicious ice cream, complete with a free topping! Thank you for making our Sunday a little sweeter. We truly appreciate your kindness, hospitality, and commitment to providing such an outstanding customer experience. If you're looking for delicious homemade ice cream, a family-friendly atmosphere, and exceptional customer service in Fenwick Island, Delaware, we highly recommend stopping by Hometown Creamery. A special thank you to Bre, Twila, Jae, and Tylah for all your help. Your team was incredibly friendly and did an amazing job balancing cleaning duties while still taking the time to engage with customers and make everyone feel welcome. Hometown Creamery is truly a great local business and a must-visit destination when you're in the Fenwick Island and Delaware beach area!

  • Leo Tarakemeh

    ★ 5 • a month ago

    Man was really nice, moved quick, and knew the shop. Customer service was a 5 overall. The ice cream is also very good. Must come again

  • Clean Freak

    ★ 5 • 3 months ago

    Absolutely AMAZING experience at Hometown Creamery! The desserts were incredible — rich, fresh, and honestly some of the best we’ve had. The chocolate cake/ice cream combo was out of this world 🍫🤍 Not only was everything delicious, but the customer service was beyond thoughtful and welcoming. They helped make a birthday celebration feel extra special, and you can truly tell they care about their customers and quality. If you’re anywhere near Selbyville, this place is a MUST. We will definitely be back!

  • Chad K.

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    Very good, thick and creamy hand dipped ice cream. My family really enjoyed the fun atmosphere.