← All stops

Island Cream Co.

Lahaina, HI • ★ 4.8 (1413 Google reviews)

Inside Island Cream Co.
Island Cream Co. photo from Google
Island Cream Co. photo from Google

The Story

Stepping into Island Cream Co. felt like a sweet trip back in time, with vintage charm filling every corner. The air hummed with happy chatter as folks savored their creamy, handcrafted delights piled high in classic scoops. Each bite brought a little taste of paradise, making Keawe Street feel like the happiest spot in Lahaina.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Tommy Lee

    ★ 5 • 3 weeks ago

    If you're craving shaved ice but can't decide on a flavor, Island Cream Co. has a self-service flavor station so you can mix and match until you find the perfect combination. If ice cream is more your style, this place is a must-visit. Their ice cream has the smooth, creamy texture of soft serve with the rich, dense flavor of gelato without any of the icy texture. The flavors rotate and are available only until they sell out, so there's always something new to try. The place is amazing, the staff are friendly and welcoming, and the quality of everything they serve keeps me coming back.

  • Ryan

    ★ 5 • 5 months ago

    The flavors that these guys come up with are INSANE! We stopped here a couple of times during our visit, trying about a dozen different flavors, and all of them were phenomenal. Easily the best ice cream we had on the island, if not anywhere. Fast and friendly service, ample parking, huge menu, and tastebud melting deliciousness. No wonder it’s so highly rated.

  • Madhu

    ★ 5 • 3 months ago

    Much recommended desert store in Maui. They have Shave Ice, Regular Ice Creams, shakes and many more. They have tastings as well before ordering it. We have tried their Shave Ice and Cookie and Cream Shake. Benefit of Shave Ice here is unlimited flavors, they have wide of flavors and all of them are unlimited. Shake is perfect in shake and taste as well. Wait time less than 5 minutes. Must try Dessert Store in Maui.

  • Dev Patel

    ★ 5 • 5 months ago

    Island Cream Co. in Maui is a fun dessert stop if you want to try a variety of local-style ice cream flavors. We went for the sampler with multiple scoops, which is a great way to taste different options in one plate. The lineup included a mix of classic and island-inspired flavors like chocolate, mango, strawberry, matcha, and ube. Each scoop was creamy and flavorful, with the tropical options standing out for their fresh taste. The sampler comes served on a wooden tray with a wooden spoon, making it easy to share and try a little bit of everything. It’s a great spot for a casual sweet treat after dinner while exploring the area. 🍨🌺