← All stops

Magic Fountain

Mattituck, NY • ★ 4.8 (1085 Google reviews)

Inside Magic Fountain
Magic Fountain photo from Google
Magic Fountain photo from Google

The Story

The cheerful red and white awning at Magic Fountain beckons, a cozy slice of yesteryear where folks gather for sweet moments. Inside, the air hums with happy chatter as families line up for scoops of their famous housemade ice cream, a true taste of summer, no matter the season. Every cone and sundae from this charming spot feels like a timeless treat, leaving you with a warm glow and a smile.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Sarah Nagib

    ★ 5 • 2 weeks ago

    The best ice cream ever! And the staff is INCREDIBLE. We drove 2 hours and it was worth every minute. We can’t wait to come back, thank you to the best girls for helping us

  • Dave Warren

    ★ 5 • 3 months ago

    The ice cream is always wonderful with awesome creative flavors!

  • Tina H

    ★ 5 • 11 months ago

    I finally got to try this ice cream spot! I passed it so many times and the line has always been so looonnnngggg! The lines moves quickly. Everyone is happy and friendly as who isn't when they are about to indulge in ice cream. Lots of choices. Try a sample if u r not sure. But not too many...I witnessed this woman on her fourth "try" 😳. Really yummy treat! U won't b disappointed 🍦

  • Feed My Wife

    ★ 4 • 11 months ago

    Did you know this spot use to be a Dairy Queen? All the way back in 1977. Love that it has turned into a long running mom and pop shop. It is certainly a staple in the community - with a line around the block! They've got some eclectic flavors - like kulfi, goat cheese, vegan options and no sugar added options. Skip the toppings, the star lost was for the stale topping - so just skip it. Because the ice cream is the star of the show and was a good consistency and sweetness. Check them out!