Maine Street Creamery
Bridgton, ME • 4.1 (44 Google reviews)
The Story
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Matthew Beckshaw
• a month ago
Unfortunately I can’t even tell you what their ice cream tastes like since they refused to serve me due to my nut allergy. If you’re a parent, do not bring kids with allergies here as I’m sure it’ll make them very upset. I have been going to ice cream shops for my entire life and not once have I been told they’d only serve me vanilla soft serve due to my allergy. I understand that they think they’re watching out for people with allergies, but then perhaps scoop ice cream from a new container with a clean scoop. That is what every single ice cream shop I’ve ever gone to has done. Yes, there will always be the chance of cross contamination but that’s at every single eatery anywhere everywhere. If this same policy was applied to each restaurant, I wouldn’t be able to eat anything. Don’t make the person with the allergy feel like they’re the problem… you should be able to organize your scooping stations and ice cream containers so that you can offer variety to everyone. It was honestly very odd and the dismissive tone as if I was the villain in the situation was jarring. I get that they were young high school or college age kids working but the manager even said they couldn’t do anything about it. The owners need to change this policy. However, I will not be going back even if they do.
Pamela Gordon
• 4 months ago
Got a milk shake there 4th of July week and it was nothing but milk and a little chocolate syrup. Cost $10.00 with tip. Didn't taste it until we were in the car and driving home. There was NO ice cream in it at all and not even enough chocolate syrup to flavor the plain milk that was in it. Called the store and spoke with someone who seemed annoyed that I was complaining about paying $10 for a glass of milk. Told me mistakes happen which is true. She verified what we paid and for what and said she would check with the person who made the "milkshake" and would get back to me. NOTE: not crowded at the time - only one person in front of us in line. Several days later - no reply. Feel very ripped off. Understand mistakes, but not being taken advantage of and made to feel like I was annoying her by bringing the matter to her attention. There are other options for ice cream in the area - try Long Lake Creamery - great ice cream, great service and great people.
Tosha Studmire
• 4 months ago
I was disappointed by my experience here. I asked to sample a flavor before ordering and was told that samples were not allowed due to “health code reasons.” As someone who enjoys trying new flavors before committing to a purchase, this was frustrating and surprising, especially for an ice cream shop. If this is truly the establishment’s policy, I would encourage the business to make it clear to customers upfront. Being unable to sample flavors made it difficult to make a purchase confidently and left me with a less-than-welcoming impression of the experience. I hope management will reconsider the policy or at least provide clearer communication to customers in the future.
Jacob van der Veen
• 3 years ago
Went for ice cream with the family after a day on the lake. Went with no expectations since there were no reviews and were blown away. High quality of the ice cream with a good amount of flavor options, sizes, and sundays. I had coconut chocolate in a waffle cone and loved it. I hope this is the first of many 5 star reviews for the Maine Street Creamery, which is totally deserved.