← All stops

Temporarily closed

Google currently lists this counter as temporarily closed. We keep the entry up for the record — call ahead before you drive out.

Mark's Homemade Ice Cream

Bucyrus, OH • 4.7 (256 Google reviews)

Inside Mark's Homemade Ice Cream
Mark's Homemade Ice Cream photo from Google
Mark's Homemade Ice Cream photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Emily Butler

    • 6 months ago

    Best ice cream ever!! I got the apple pie flavor and it’s incredible! Definitely recommend if you love apple pie! And the servers did this to my daughter’s ice cream and it came out so darn cute! And shout out to how sweet and patient the servers were with us considering it was our first time there!

  • Tim Stickle

    • 6 months ago

    Was on a day trip with a friend and stopped in Bucyrus for ice cream at Mark’s Homemade Ice Cream. I had peach, Rachel had black cherry. After our first bite we looked at each other, sort of aghast. We both said we couldn’t taste any flavor. So we switched and they tasted exactly the same. Although “taste” really isn’t the correct word, they FELT the same: just a good texture with almost zero flavor. It was just frozen paste, utterly bland. We’re from Toledo where we have Handel’s (where the flavors truly pop), so this was a big disappointment. We couldn’t finish it. It’s not good.

  • Dj Sullivan

    • 3 years ago

    Absolutely some of the best ice cream I have eaten anywhere ever!!!!! I will stop here always. Every time I pass through, it is that good. I got the buckeye milkshake, my wife, the butter pecan, and my daughter, the strawberry cheesecake. All of us agreed on how good it was. A must try

  • Taylor Merritt

    • 5 months ago

    We had Mark’s Homemade Ice Cream Truck at our work event for the second year in a row and, once again, it was a hit! They are great to work with each year for a reasonable price. Their ice cream is just as good as their service!