Mary's Mountain Cookies
Cheyenne, WY • ★ 4.7 (327 Google reviews)
The Story
Stepping into Mary's Mountain Cookies on Lincolnway feels like a sweet, comforting hug from a bygone era, with its charming retro parlor atmosphere. The air hums with the promise of freshly baked wonders, each cookie a testament to simple, delicious craftsmanship. Every bite is a delightful journey back to childhood, perfectly satisfying that homespun craving for something truly special.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Randi Butler
★ 5 • 3 months ago
Nick was fabulous! He provided quick service, was personable, knowledgeable and not pushy. I got a "buy 6 get 2 free" pack. 3 m&m which my man loves. 3 chocolate chip that I think are great. 1 peanut butter cup that looks really good. 1 turtle rock that I can't wait to try. Plus an ice cream cone which Nick turned upside down in a cup for me because I had to drive home. Everything looks great, tastes good but the best part of today was Nick.
Drea
★ 5 • a month ago
I had an oatmeal cookie and it was phenomenal! I love that they offer to warm them up for you. I was in town visiting from California and so glad I stopped by. Would definitely love to visit again someday 😋🍪
Michelle Anne
★ 5 • 2 months ago
We stopped after dinner on our first night in Cheyenne, and then went back again the next night. The cookies are absolutely delicious! We had the crème brûlée cookie, chocolate chip cookie, cloud puff iced sugar cookie and the chocolate chip cookie sandwiches-which had the best buttercream icing! Now regretting that we didn’t stay a third night to try the other varieties! Please visit this small local shop - there definitely is a cookie for everyone’s taste!
Jeff Owens
★ 5 • a month ago
Visited from Southwestern Indiana this afternoon while we stopped in town. Purchased several different cookie flavors as well as the cinnamon rolls. All have phenomenal flavor and are delicious. If you are in the area this is definitely worth a stop.
