← All stops

Mastodons Ice Cream Co.

Johnstown, OH • 5 (112 Google reviews)

Inside Mastodons Ice Cream Co.
Mastodons Ice Cream Co. photo from Google
Mastodons Ice Cream Co. photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Sarah Yang

    • 2 months ago

    Such a cute, fun, and unique ice cream shop! The entire place is filled with beautiful artwork, fun decor, and good history (the name of the ice cream shop) which makes the experience so much more than just getting ice cream. They have a fantastic variety of ice cream flavors, plus waffles, milkshakes, and even ice cream flight, which are such a fun way to try different flavors! I highly recommend checking this place out! Great atmosphere, delicious treats, friendly service and such a fun experience. Definitely worth a visit!

  • Robert Holland

    • 6 months ago

    The owner Jo was there and super friendly. We tried some ice cream and landed on the banana pudding cup and we were blown away at how great the ice cream is! The only thing as sweet as their ice cream is the service and atmosphere. The prices are low for the quality you get. Keep it up, we are now regulars!! It was so good I forgot to get a photo!!

  • Tomislav Matanovic

    • 3 months ago

    If you're looking ice cream in Central Ohio, **Mastodons Ice Cream Co.** in Johnstown is an absolute must-visit! From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with genuine smiles and a warm, family-friendly atmosphere that makes you feel right at home. It's clear this isn't just another ice cream shop—it's a place built on community, kindness, and passion. The ice cream is incredible, with a fantastic selection of classic favorites and creative flavors that keep you coming back to try something new. Everything tastes fresh, rich, and high quality, and the menu offers fun treats like shakes, waffle creations, dipped cheesecake, and more, so there's something for everyone. What really sets Mastodons apart is the exceptional customer service. The owners and staff truly care about every customer and go above and beyond to make each visit special. You can tell they love what they do, and that positive energy shines through in every scoop they serve. Johnstown is lucky to have such an amazing locally owned business. Whether you're stopping by after dinner, bringing the family, or just treating yourself, Mastodons Ice Cream Co. delivers a five-star experience every time. Highly recommended—you've earned a customer for life!

  • Robert Olinger

    • 5 months ago

    Where do I even begin? If I could give Mastodon’s Ice Cream a million stars, I would. My family and I are frequent visitors, but this place is so much more than just an ice cream shop. Mr. and Mrs. "Mastodon" are the kind of business owners every small town hopes for. They don’t just serve ice cream — they show up for the community. I coach youth soccer for the local JYAA, and a few days before our last visit, I stopped in to let them know I was planning to bring our team in after a game. They told me they actually weren’t open that day, but without hesitation, they said they would come in and open the shop just for our team. That alone says everything you need to know. I ended up talking the opposing team into joining us too, and the owners themselves were there hand-scooping every custom order for both teams. They didn’t have to do that. They could have easily said no. But their willingness to make that exception for a group of kids says a lot about who they are and what kind of business they run. Mastodon’s has always been a strong supporter of Johnstown, Ohio, and honestly, they are a great example of what a local business should be. Not every business has to open on a day off for a youth soccer team, but that kind of generosity, kindness, and community support deserves to be recognized. And on top of all that, the ice cream is absolutely delicious. Highly recommend Mastodon’s Ice Cream — and definitely try their Alani milkshakes!