Temporarily closed
Google currently lists this counter as temporarily closed. We keep the entry up for the record — call ahead before you drive out.
May's Freez
Lewisburg, PA • 4.3 (72 Google reviews)
The Story
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Peter Lupkowski
• 4 months ago
It was hot, we got ice cream. It’s a federal law… I think. Folks behind the screen were nice and our ice cream and drinks were served quickly. Try a Stormer! Parking along side and in back. Careful their neighbors are testy about sharing spots, probably didn’t have their ice cream yet!
Lew Bryson
• 3 months ago
Stopped by last week, first time. GREAT retro look, a classic roadside ice cream stand. People in front of me kept changing their orders, making substitutions; they were ANNOYING, but the kid behind the counter took it all in stride, very pleasant. He got me a teaberry milkshake that was delicious. Love that they had teaberry available. Will be back.
Aaron Stepanik
• 3 months ago
Was there mid-August and had the peanut butter cup stormer. While I received a large potion for a small which was better than expected, the flavor was just not there. It didn't taste very peanut-buttery with the cups. Very bland and tasteless. Tasted like generic no-name brand peanut butter cups that have no flavor, which is a shame because that was always my go-to at any ice cream place. Hopefully the other flavors aren't this bad. Won't be back anytime soon as that experience was disappointing.
Deborah Kennard
• a month ago
The menu was pretty overwhelming, so I asked the young man working on September 17, 2026 in the evening if he could help me choose something. I explained that I wanted something with peanut butter and other things mixed into it, but instead of offering a suggestion, he just kept asking, “Well, what do you want?” That was exactly what I was trying to figure out! After going back and forth, I finally gave up and didn’t order anything. My husband ordered his item, and I left with nothing. I was disappointed because a little friendliness and guidance would have made such a difference, especially with such a large menu. Just a couple of specific questions would have helped me make a decision. I was so unhappy leaving with nothing.