← All stops

Milk Can Hamburgers & Custard

Muskego, WI • 4.2 (949 Google reviews)

Inside Milk Can Hamburgers & Custard
Milk Can Hamburgers & Custard photo from Google
Milk Can Hamburgers & Custard photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Tabitha Yang

    • 3 months ago

    First time here, heard food was great, ordered a bacon cheeseburger, fries, brownie sundae. Sat outside since no seating was available inside due to being busy. A young worker kept coming around asking if we needed anything which I thought was nice! Custard came first, looked okay, didn't taste very good - the custard didn’t have a creaminess it had more of a taffy pull, had some bites and tossed it. The burger looked amazing but the patty itself wasn’t flavorful, the meat broke apart like a frozen patty and cheese didn’t have much flavor to it. Pickles were nice: crunchy, flavorful, and not too thin or thick. Fries looked pale and lightly seasoned. They were okay, the seasoning could use more of a punch of flavor. Overall not terrible, not great!

  • Kendra Sanchez

    • 5 months ago

    This place was super cute! The food was great and the service was excellent! A family friendly place that doesn’t break the bank. We will definitely be back.

  • 1badruckus

    • 2 months ago

    I stopped at Milk Can on my way through Muskego. I was looking for a traditional type burger joint. I kept it simple and ordered the Milk Can hamburger with fries. Both were very good. I would definitely return. The dining room was clean. The service was a little slow.

  • Scott W

    • 2 years ago

    Been here several times. It's a little pricey, but it's always been good. This time we got a couple burger, Jack's Gold and the Milk Can Burger. Both wer excellent. Shared an order of Onion Rings and a Chocolate Malt. Everything was very good. Quick, hot and tasty. The servers came around during the meal to ask if everything was good and if we needed anything. Nice touch.