Milltown Ice Cream Depot
Milltown, NJ • 4.6 (808 Google reviews)
The Story
Busy, old-timey spot with window service for big portions of ice cream in many flavors, plus shakes.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Aalia
• 3 years ago
Such a cute local ice cream spot. Parking in the back and behind that a little park with tables. Standard flavors and some fun ones nothing too unique. Large portion sizes. It's a walk up outdoor order only so be sure to bundle up if it's chilly and there's a line. I've had the Peanut Butter Ripple (don't recommend it's mostly vanilla with little peanut butter), Starwberry (so good! With real strawberries and not too sweet), and the Butter Pecan Low Fat (tastes like the standard. This one was actually the sweetest tasting of the three and my favorite).
Jaime Brownell
• 7 years ago
This was my first time visiting this ice cream shop. This is a new location on Main St. for this store. The portions here a huge. A medium cone will satisfy two people. They have a nice variety of ice cream flavors and italian ices. You can order the usual treats, including sundaes, banana splits and milk shakes. They offer both cones or cups The staff is very friendly and service is quick. There a few tables inside to sit at and a couple of benches outside. A minor drawback is that not much parking is available.
Scott Harrigan
• 9 years ago
You get a lot for a little here. Just a baby size ice cream would be a medium at other places. This place can be very busy at times but the staff does a decent job in keeping the line moving. One thing to know about this place CASH ONLY! And they are not kidding. There is a bank nearby with an ATM so stop there first. Also no public bathroom...just FYI. There is a baby size and a "under the counter" size that is the smallest they have. I took a photo of the under the counter size. Regardless of size the ice cream here is amazing.
Yusef AI “Crowned” Emperor
• a year ago
Love love love love love love this place and their customer service wouldn't get ice cream anywhere else. Super family orientated. Latest creation Eclair mixed with cookies and cream and hot fudge topped with cinnamon churro topped with cones crushed and cookie crumbles