← All stops

Temporarily closed

Google currently lists this counter as temporarily closed. We keep the entry up for the record — call ahead before you drive out.

Mister Goodies Ice Cream

Lynchburg, VA • 4.8 (1533 Google reviews)

Inside Mister Goodies Ice Cream
Mister Goodies Ice Cream photo from Google
Mister Goodies Ice Cream photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Casey

    • a month ago

    We will continue to return to Mister Goodies for their amazing ice cream, portions, and prices. It is always such a treat to look forward to and we have no complaints about their product. Our main complaint is associated with the delivery of the product. Every encounter we have had with the staff has been disappointing. Each employee is inconsiderate in their manner of serving, frequently leaving us feeling rushed, unseen, and uncomfortable. Each staff member seems tied up in their role they forget to be genuinely friendly and come off as insincere. We have also noticed the team is back and forth between a shed for the dipped ice cream. As a certified ServSafe Manager, I find this bothersome as they carry the bare product from a shed back into the trailer to hand it out. I think at this point in their business, they could afford more efficient facility. The amazing product quality and poor team member attitude is consistent. I always value the product, but the experience overall is consistently undermined by the staff.

  • China' Williams

    • a month ago

    When I say this is the BEST ice cream spot I’ve been to in the last few months, I mean it! 🍦🙌🏽 I’ve visited at least five other locations throughout Virginia, and this one is hands down my #1. From the ice cream and pricing to the atmosphere and overall experience, everything was on point. Definitely worth a visit—I’ll be back!!!

  • Alexandria B

    • 8 months ago

    I have been coming to Mister Goodies for years and I have never been disappointed. I love their weekly rotating flavors, and I have made plenty of evening trips just specifically for em! The menu is very expansive & there are plenty of options for everyone. The prices are super reasonable, their ingredients are fresh and tasty, & everyone has always been lovely & friendly. Mister Goodies is a MUST VISIT dessert shop for everyone who lives here and tourists/visitors!! 🍦🫶

  • Beth DeBiase

    • 2 months ago

    I had a very enjoyable experience yesterday. I spoke with a Blonde girl, I believe her name was Alli (not sure on spelling). She was patient with me while I decided what I wanted to treat myself to and allowed me to ask as many questions as needed. She was smiling and provided amazing customer service! Give this girl a raise! She is the epitome of customer service! Thank you for a great experience, Alli!