Modern Milk Bar
Sheffield, MA • 4.7 (156 Google reviews)
The Story
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
leonard hilado
• 3 months ago
Modern Milk Bar has a lot going for it. The shop has a great modern atmosphere, with comfortable seating and a really nice setting that makes it an enjoyable place to sit, relax, and have some ice cream. The staff were very friendly, welcoming, and helpful, which definitely added to the experience. The ice cream itself was good and flavorful, but overall it didn't quite have that wow factor I was hoping for. My biggest disappointment was the scoop size—the portions felt pretty small for an ice cream shop, especially compared with what you might expect for the price. Overall, it's a nice spot with great service and atmosphere, and the ice cream tastes good. With slightly more generous portions or something that made the flavors stand out a little more, it could easily be a higher-rated experience for me.
Daniel Donnelly
• 5 months ago
Friendly staff and delicious ice cream, made into shakes, sundaes and cones. Countertop and small tables for eating inside, and benches outside. Braziers available when needed.
Reb Pen
• a year ago
OUTSTANDING HOMEMADE ICE CREAM!!!! The Pumpkin Pie was amazing!!! The Housatonic Swamp Thing (chocolate) was delicious! If you’re on Route 7 between Sheffield MA and Kent CT, you should come see owners Lee and Raven. They have a great selection of flavors, some vegan. They are open seasonally.
Ralph Rodriguez
• 2 months ago
I took four Big City Slicker friends there after dinner on Saturday. We all loved our selections. I had black raspberry ice cream in a chocolate rimmed waffle cone. The flavors were deeply delicious, best in the region, easily, and if I had just a bit more experience I'd probably expand that region to include many counties across several states. I'm now kicking myself for not taking a couple of pints home. But then...I shall return!