Temporarily closed
Google currently lists this counter as temporarily closed. We keep the entry up for the record — call ahead before you drive out.
Monona Bait & Ice Cream Shop
Monona, WI • 4.4 (256 Google reviews)
The Story
That cozy spot on Winnequah Road always feels like a step back in time, where the hum of happy chatter mixes with the promise of a perfect treat. You can almost taste the summer in their creamy sundaes and juicy burgers, right alongside the friendly folks grabbing their afternoon catch. It’s a genuine slice of Americana, where every visit brings a sweet memory and a touch of Wisconsin charm.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Rock Cande
• 2 months ago
We ordered lunch for a group of four and it was well worth the wait. This isn't fast food, it is prepared to order and fresh. There was a young man working the counter, as the owner was helping to prepare food, when it got busy. A crowd of people entered as we had finished ordering, but the young man who was working, never broke a sweat and was polite and friendly to each customer. The place was spotless, even the restroom was clean. I used to bring my kids here when they were little and it's pretty cool to share it now with the next generation in our family. I really can't say enough about what a great experience we have each time. Thank you, Monona Bait and Tackle!
Lissy Kettleson
• 4 months ago
we agree with some other reviews we saw - the owner was not happy that we were there AT ALL. he wasn’t outright mean but the vibe was very unwelcoming. I recommend you just go to the chocolate shop, it’s cheaper for bigger portions and better ice cream in my opinion. if you’re gonna run an ice cream shop I suggest you at least fake a better attitude, it really put a bad taste in our mouths which is so sad cause we have great memories from our childhood.
Amy Inkonglad
• 2 months ago
Do Not Come Here! We stopped here because we wanted to support what looked like a cute local ice cream shop, but unfortunately, we really regretted our decision. The person working, who I believe may have been the owner, was extremely unwelcoming and acted as though our being there was an inconvenience rather than appreciated business. The shop is cash only, so you cannot use a credit or debit card. If you don’t have cash, there is an ATM, but it charges a $3 fee just to withdraw $20. There were five of us. One person didn’t want much ice cream, so I ordered two scoops for $7-$8 intending to share with him. We simply asked for an extra empty cup, and the person working told us it would be another 50 cents for the cup. It wasn’t really about the 50 cents. It was the attitude and the overall experience. Everything felt unnecessarily unfriendly and transactional. We left feeling like our business wasn’t wanted. Customer service makes a huge difference, especially for a neighborhood ice cream shop. It’s such a common sense but I guess not… I would not recommend this place. There are plenty of other ice cream shops where customers are actually made to feel welcome and appreciated.
Andromeda
• 4 months ago
My kiddo and I went in for what we thought would be a quick lunch of ice cream and hot dogs on a summer weekday. We intentionally ordered food that would be quick because we had to get somewhere. No line, no one else waiting for food, and somehow it took 40 minutes to get 2 hot dogs. It looked like the person in the kitchen was preparing a 4 course meal, I have no idea what was going on back there with all the chopping and frying. By the time we finally got the hot dogs we were full up on ice cream and took the hot dogs home and ate them cold later. No one batted an eye, as if that was the normal wait time for hot dogs. Plan accordingly.