Mr G's Ice Cream
Gettysburg, PA • 4.8 (2579 Google reviews)
The Story
Cheery spot set in 2 quaint redbrick homes dishing up housemade ice cream, sundaes & shakes.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Thomas B
• a month ago
Very good ice cream but certainly not the best we ever had. Quick walk-up window service with friendly staff member. Prices are very reasonable and there is a place along the side of the shop to sit and enjoy your treats. Parking here is a major problem with limited availability close-by - not their fault but it is something to note if just making a quick stop for ice cream. FYI - be advised they charge 3% fee is you use a credit card, so we recommend you bring cash. Overall, would still buy from this shop if we visit here again. FYI - forgot to take photos of the ice cream treats, but once they arrived did not care about taking a photo as much as we wanted to devour the ice cream.
Miss Daisy Sweet
• 4 months ago
So glad we didn't miss this place! 🍦✨ Total impressions checked for both taste and vibes! Despite the long line, the staff kept things moving super fast. The prices are totally reasonable too. I got the salted caramel + marshmallow combo, while the kids went with classic vanilla and cookie dough. Every single scoop was amazing. It totally lived up to the hype and did not disappoint at all!
Amanda - Lambies on the Go
• 4 months ago
Mr. G’s is hands down my favorite ice cream shop in Gettysburg, and we make a point to stop every time we’re in town. They make all of their ice cream in house, which is becoming harder and harder to find, and you can absolutely taste the difference. The flavors rotate depending on availability, but my favorite is Death by Chocolate. It features light chocolate ice cream with ribbons of chocolate sauce and soft, fudgy brownie chunks throughout. It sells out quickly, and after trying it, you’ll understand why. The service is always fast and incredibly friendly. The staff is happy to explain the flavors and help you find one you’ll love. The atmosphere is just as special as the ice cream. The shop is located inside the historic Twin Sycamores House and has both indoor and outdoor seating. One of the coolest features is the beautiful Witness Tree in the yard that stood during the Battle of Gettysburg and when Abraham Lincoln traveled through town. If you’re looking for the best ice cream in Gettysburg, this is it. Homemade ice cream, wonderful people, and a truly unique historic setting make Mr. G’s a place we look forward to visiting every trip.
Smitha Nair
• 4 months ago
This weekend, I brought ice cream from Mr. G's Ice Cream all the way to New York for my sister and her family to enjoy. I packed Mocha Fudge, Cookie Dough, and Salted Caramel with dry ice, and everything traveled perfectly. The Salted Caramel was my sister’s favorite, while the Cookie Dough was a huge hit with my nephew and his girlfriend. The Salted Caramel is rich, smooth, and absolutely delicious, and the Cookie Dough has the perfect amount of cookie dough pieces swirled throughout the creamy ice cream. Their coffee ice cream is honestly the best I’ve had anywhere. While I was in New York, I tried coffee ice cream from another well-known place and compared it to others I’ve had before, and I can confidently say that nothing beats Mr. G’s coffee ice cream. The cold brew shakes made with their coffee ice cream are my absolute favorite. Mr. G’s is truly my happy place, and being able to share it with family in New York while celebrating America’s 250th Anniversary made the experience even more special. -Dr.Scoops