← All stops

Muller's Creamery

Toms River, NJ • 4.9 (143 Google reviews)

Inside Muller's Creamery
Muller's Creamery photo from Google
Muller's Creamery photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • AnaVictoria Miranda

    • 6 months ago

    The ice cream is great! The owners are so sweet and friendly. Best shake I have ever had! Found my new favorite ice cream spot 🩷

  • B-rittt

    • 5 months ago

    Absolutely amazing experience today! I stopped in with my daughter and a friend, and we are still talking about how good the ice cream was. We got the Mint Oreo, and it was honestly one of the best ice creams I’ve ever had. Everything tasted so fresh and homemade, and you can tell they take a lot of pride in what they do. The shop was spotless, the atmosphere was great, and the owners were incredibly kind. The best part was how sweet they were with my daughter. They even took the time to bring her in the back and show her how they make the ice cream, which completely made her day. It’s rare to find a place with both amazing ice cream and genuinely wonderful people behind it. We will definitely be back!

  • Matt “Soup” Foley

    • 6 months ago

    We came here for friend's 38th. Said friend is also very lactose intolerant and heavily enjoyed the vegan ice cream offerings. The rest of us greatly enjpyed our selections as well. Great ingredients = great quality ice cream.

  • Tracy G.

    • 2 months ago

    My fiancé and I have been coming to NJ on vacation for years now, and always make it a point to try 1 - 2 new ice cream shops when we are here. This was our first time at Muller’s Creamery, and the first time we looked at each other and said “we can stop trying new ones now!” We were blown away by how delicious this ice cream is! A lot of shops claim to have homemade ice cream, but you can tell this is completely made from scratch with no added junk. The flavors are rich but not overwhelming and it’s probably the creamiest, smoothest ice cream we’ve ever had. My other half is a mint chip aficionado, and said this is the absolute best mint chip he’s ever had. And the chocolate I had will be what I compare all chocolate ice cream to now. Not only is the ice cream out of this world, but the owners have to be some of the nicest people we’ve met here! We got there just a couple minutes before closing (I read the time online wrong 🤦🏻‍♀️) and they told us to come on in and take our time, chatted with us about things to do in the area, and were just so incredibly kind. The only thing I don’t like is how far away they are from where we live! This will definitely be a repeat stop on our NJ trips!