New Hartford Creamery
New Hartford, IA • ★ 5 (32 Google reviews)
The Story
The New Hartford Creamery, nestled on Packwaukee Street, offers a sweet escape where the air buzzes with happy chatter and the clink of spoons. Step inside this retro parlor and feel time slow down as you savor scoops of homemade joy, each bite a taste of pure, simple comfort. It's a delightful small-town gem, serving up frosted delights and a heaping side of wholesome charm that warms the soul.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
julie mintey
★ 5 • 2 months ago
What a wonderful little ice cream store. Staff is always very pleasant and have REAL Ice cream. It is decorated vintage style and have a nice outdoor area to sit. Will be back:)
Heather Armstrong
★ 5 • 2 years ago
We stopped in on a Saturday afternoon, before leaving town after a family reunion. We were NOT disappointed! My Mom had a dish of creamcicle, I had a 16oz creamcicle shake, and my son's friend had a creamcicle sundae topped with gummi bears. My son had a 16oz Monster Cookie shake. My fiance had a 16oz "Heat and Humidity" shake, but replaced the lemon flavored ice cream with black cherry, and didn't get the lemon cookies in it. It was all SOOO delicious! Our total was only $25.50 for all 5 of us. Everyone was so friendly in there... staff and customers. Next time we go there I plan to check out that Key Lime Pie flavor! We strongly suggest that if you find yourself in New Hartford, Iowa... You find your way to the Creamery! It's right off Main St!
Adele Heilskov
★ 5 • 2 months ago
Just stopped for ice cream. It was such great ice cream! The decor is so cute and service awesome. We will be back.
Chuck Varnum
★ 5 • 2 years ago
Wow! A scooped ice cream shop like the old days! The Creamery has about 12 different flavors of ice cream that rotate all the time. The flavors are so good, made with real cream. The interior of the store is an eclectic mix of antique/vintage items. They have a huge candy bin, so if you need a piece or two, they got you. They do shakes, banana splits, etc. But we usually just get scoops. Nice outdoor seating in the afternoon/evening shade. We will always come back!
