Nickey's Ice Cream
Warrenville, SC • ★ 4.9 (371 Google reviews)
The Story
Nickey's Ice Cream, a true slice of Americana on Jefferson Davis Hwy, welcomes you with its bright, cheerful retro charm and the sweet promise of a perfect treat. Inside, the air hums with happy chatter as folks pick from classic scoops piled high or sip on a creamy, old-fashioned malt. It’s a delightful stop where every bite of ice cream tastes like a sunny summer day, making memories one delicious spoonful at a time.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
angela pray
★ 5 • 3 weeks ago
I stopped by Nicky’s today after class at ATC. I had been at Pizza Hut and asked one of the employees if they had tried the ice cream yet. She said, “Yes! It’s so good. Treat yourself!” 😂 I’ve been thinking about trying it, so I decided to finally give it a shot. I’m so glad I did! The young gentleman behind the counter was so nice, and I ordered two flavors: Mint Chocolate Chip and Cookie Monster. 🍪🍦 Cookie Monster (or “C is for Cookie,” as some call it) is one of my absolute favorites. I’ve only ever had it at Flanigan’s and Pink Dipper, so I was really excited to see it here. I brought both flavors home, and when I tried the Cookie Monster… WOW. It was honestly the best I’ve ever had! It was so creamy and full of flavor. I told my daughter, “This is SO good! I wonder who they order their ice cream from?” Then she started reading the reviews and we discovered that it’s actually homemade! 😍 Needless to say, I’ll definitely be back. You’ve got yourself a new customer! 🍦❤️
Paige B.
★ 5 • 8 months ago
Cute little icecream shop. Great service and super yummy fresh icecream made daily! I got the coffee toffee crunch..... it was super good! Highly recommend if youre a coffee lover like me. There is also cute little spaces to take selfies!
Eric Parks
★ 5 • 2 months ago
Wonderful place. The interior is open, colorful and bright. The staff is friendly and welcoming. I had a scoop of chocolate chip mint, which was very good, and a scoop of banana pudding ice cream, which blew my mind. It was heavenly. Can’t wait to go back and have some more of that.
William Moore
★ 5 • 3 months ago
Went there for the first time today. Amazing ice-cream. Had the Banana Pudding ice-cream in a waffle cone bowl. This was the real deal. It was delicious and did not taste artificial. Just the right blend of banana and waffles. The staff was pleasant. We will definitely be back!
