← All stops

Nutter's Ice Cream

Sharpsburg, MD • ★ 4.8 (1572 Google reviews)

Inside Nutter's Ice Cream
Nutter's Ice Cream photo from Google
Nutter's Ice Cream photo from Google

The Story

The sweet scent of sugar and cream always welcomed you in, a cozy hug from a bygone era in Sharpsburg. Inside Nutter's, every scoop of inventive ice cream felt like a small celebration, a burst of joy in charming, old-fashioned surroundings. You’d leave with a happy heart and a sticky smile, already dreaming of your next delicious visit to that beloved parlor.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Bethanie B.

    ★ 5 • 2 months ago

    Amazing ice cream. It's become a tradition to take the kids any time we have a river day. Some times there is quite a long line, but definitely worth the wait. I have 5 kids, and we are able to get everyone what they want for $20 or less. Great service, great ice cream, if I could give 100 stars I would! 😊

  • Ashley

    ★ 1 • 5 months ago

    UNSANITARY!!! I don’t understand how people love this place. Are the prices great? Yes. But at what cost? The two times we went to try it out over the summer, I noticed the lady scooping the ice cream wasn’t wearing gloves. Even though it goes against my better judgement, I could POSSIBLY be okay with it but when my ice cream being scooped is rolling across the servers bandaid on their finger, that’s where I have to draw the line 🤢 Two different occasions this EXACT scenario happened! Mind you, these visits were months apart. I tried not to care but my food was literally touching someone’s contaminated bandaid. I threw it away. I shouldn’t have even paid and I regret not reporting to health department. Will not be back. The only reason I attempted a second visit was because I was hoping the first time was a fluke. If they don’t care about bandaids touching peoples food, I’m sure there are plenty of other health code violations that exist in this place.

  • Steve Powell

    ★ 5 • 4 months ago

    Great ice-cream and wonderful prices! Beautiful little town. Great spot to visit.

  • Tatiana Hoover

    ★ 5 • 2 years ago

    A little out of the way, but a great find!! The portions are enormous! The place is a little museum of odds and ends and the woman who served us was quite a character. Very friendly. There are lots of flavors to chose from, and I’m not kidding on the huge portions. Worth every calorie. There is a clean restroom and the ice cream parlor is accessible. No tables inside, it’s order and carry out. Street parking.