← All stops

Old Fashioned Ice Cream

Selma, NC • 4.5 (107 Google reviews)

Inside Old Fashioned Ice Cream
Old Fashioned Ice Cream photo from Google
Old Fashioned Ice Cream photo from Google

The Story

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Suzanne Shabdue

    • 4 months ago

    Nice creamery. Great service. Ice cream was good. Not the best that Ive had, but maybe that was because of what flavor I chose- coffee cookie chip. Offer lots of flavors. Easy to find.

  • Darren Hood

    • 5 months ago

    The best ice cream I've ever had in my life. Definitely old fashioned, so many great flavors Great friendly service and prices very light on the Wallet. Best value for the dollar.

  • Bryan Skipper

    • a year ago

    Customer service is garbage. I ordered a banana split and had 5 others in my party. All others in my party were served and then 4 customers after that ordered after me. My party was almost done before I even got mine. It ruined the whole experience for me. The icecream was actually really good if I could have enjoyed it.

  • Beth Caves

    • 4 months ago

    3 minutes to closing as we were right across the street at an appt. There were people in there. The OPEN light was on and the site said OPEN. WE literally just wanted one scoop each for the two of us. The second we walked in the door, three employees said they were closing, Sorry. Like, ok. I guess a sweet treat can be found anywhere else. 🤨