Old Fashioned Ice Cream
West Babylon, NY • 4.7 (770 Google reviews)
The Story
Cones, ice cream cakes & other frozen treats are served at this homey neighborhood fixture.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Nabiha K.
• 6 months ago
Have to give ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ ⭐️ for the staff who were working non stop and with a smile on their faces and were very professional and friendly! Definitely a good place for quality ice cream BUT I would like the owners to accommodate the customers for a more sit down relaxed environment outside the store. Why I can only give 3 stars for now. T-shirt size I wanted they didn’t have a Large or a medium. Small and 2xl were the only ones available and staff didn’t know when will it be in stock. Bummer! Since inside of the store is a very small space to stand and make a line and so it goes around the store. It would make so much more sense to designate parking more creatively and place seatings for families to sit and enjoy their treats. Perhaps place barricades a bit further away around the store so no cars off the streets can come speeding down at customers waiting in line outside. Adding windows for outside orders instead of cramping everyone inside would also work. Most places have window service/drive through service especially if it’s a small storefront. I couldn’t keep up with who is next and who is already taken care of so had to stay alert and not be skipped accidentally. A bit more structured environment will definitely bring a wonderful experience for everyone. Will pay a visit again when weather is warmer and hopefully management has taken suggestions seriously. For now definitely stop by and try out their many different flavors but be prepared for a long line and difficult parking situation.
Emily Lively
• 2 months ago
Honestly so disappointed!! The girl behind the counter was so unfriendly and seemed like she had better places to be. The portion size for the prize is also absurd. The fact that this was $6.50 is insane. Literally anywhere else would have been better and worth the money. Sad and disappointing
Munzoor Ahmed
• 4 months ago
I stopped by Old Fashioned Ice Cream in West Babylon for the first time, and it was a wonderful experience. The ice cream was rich, creamy, and full of flavor, with plenty of choices to suit every taste. The portions were generous, the staff was welcoming, and the service was quick despite the crowd. The classic, old-fashioned atmosphere adds to the charm and makes it a great place to enjoy a treat with family or friends. I'll definitely be coming back to try more flavors. Highly recommended!
Azeem Khan
• 5 months ago
This is the best ice cream in all of Long Island. I’ve been coming here for a bit over a year at this point because my wife was looking for good ice cream. And since I started getting it’s become almost a weekly family ritual. All the ice cream is made on premises and is reasonably priced as well. And the soft serve is amazing too. The staff are super friendly as well, which honestly makes a big difference. Genuinely couldn’t sing enough praises for this place. Check it out if you’re considering it at all.