← All stops

Old Timey Ice Cream

Spring Creek, NV • ★ 4.8 (50 Google reviews)

Inside Old Timey Ice Cream
Old Timey Ice Cream photo from Google
Old Timey Ice Cream photo from Google

The Story

Stepping into Old Timey Ice Cream felt like a sweet trip back in time, with the cheerful hum of happy chatter filling the air. Swirls of classic flavors piled high on cones promised simple, delicious joy under the glow of the parlor lights. Each creamy scoop offered a taste of yesteryear, making memories as comforting as a summer afternoon.

From the Counter

Recent Google reviews

  • Jennifer Fuller

    ★ 5 • 9 months ago

    If you’re a fan of delicious gooey, one of a kind grilled cheese sandwiches and the most DELICIOUS tomato bisque soup ever—I highly recommend you give Old Timey a try! Seriously, so delicious and the customer service is ALWAYS over the top! And don’t even get me started on their one of a kind specials! This Reuben and German potato salad was *chefs kiss*!

  • Emma Bear

    ★ 5 • 3 months ago

    Staff was amazing and very knowledgeable on answering questions that I had. Wore smiles on their faces and were nice. Amazing ice cream flavors as well, I especially love their accommodations to people with allergies like gluten free options and dairy free.

  • Danielle Harvey

    ★ 3 • 5 months ago

    After going 4 times now, here is my honest review. I like that the ingredients are natural and fresh but everything on the menu is extremely expensive. Especially for what you get. I don’t mind paying nearly $20 for a burger but everything just seems “ok”. I hope she is successful but at those prices it should be better.

  • Tiffany Bushman

    ★ 5 • 9 months ago

    I have said and will continue to say this would be my death row meal-specifically the bananas foster milk shake (adult or not) and the John Wayne or jalapeno popper grilled cheese. Worth the drive and the sweetest owner!