Temporarily closed
Google currently lists this counter as temporarily closed. We keep the entry up for the record — call ahead before you drive out.
Poppy's Ice Cream Parlour
Barnegat Light, NJ • 4.8 (222 Google reviews)
The Story
The sweet scent of waffle cones and sugar hung in the air like a summer dream as we stepped into Poppy's, a welcome burst of retro charm. Bright red booths and a cheerful hum of conversation made every scoop of their creamy ice cream taste like a little slice of yesteryear's joy. It was the kind of place where a simple sundae felt like a grand occasion, leaving you with a warm smile and a sticky, happy memory.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Brian Collins
• a month ago
It was the most delicious ice cream I’ve ever had. The mint chip tasted like real mint,and not just chemicals. The cookie dough tasted very authentic and sweet. It was also very cheap,7 dollars for 2 people. The service was also excellent, they even gave us testing spoons to see which flavors we liked. And when we accidentally spilled a bit,they offered to replace it for free! It was also a big portion size, perfectly sized. It is a true 5 star ice cream spot, never had a better ice cream in my 60 long years of living. You have to go here if you want to experience true,authentic,cheap ice cream and the nicest people I’ve ever met .
Alissa Mirchuk
• 4 years ago
Delicious Ice cream with creative flavors! Definitely one of our favorite places to go when we are near Barnegate Light . Staff was friendly and the line moved quick. And there is both indoor seating and outdoor seating . Although, I wish the portions were a little larger. This was 2 scoops :( not quite the same value as others in the area. But it had great flavor
Rachel L
• 4 years ago
The waffle bowls are so good. Tried the cinnamon churro and it was excellent. Also had the nutter butter which was a win. Great little spot that serves fun flavors of hard ice cream
Norm Riley
• a year ago
Perfect after dinner tradition, time the line and enjoy a scoop of deliciousness. Fun experience - the wait, the flavor options, the very hard working servers!