Shake's Frozen Custard
Fayetteville, AR • ★ 4.6 (494 Google reviews)
The Story
The bright neon sign welcomes you into a sweet haven, where the scent of vanilla and chocolate hangs thick and inviting in the air. Each spoonful of rich, creamy custard feels like a nostalgic hug, a perfect old-fashioned treat that melts on your tongue. It’s a cheerful stop on a sunny day, where laughter mingles with the clinking of spoons, making every visit a little slice of Americana comfort.
From the Counter
Recent Google reviews
Nicholas Bruce
★ 3 • 3 months ago
First time visit review... My biggest issue, was one of the lights was buzzing extremely loud, that as I was in line, several others even commented on it, and it gave me a headache, also had issues reading the menu either because of the format or the buzzing. The treat was delicious, and service was good. Could be a little louder when announcing a ready item, as 2 things were grabbed incorrectly while I was there. But no, it's the buzzing, I can't, the 'tism in me was absolutely screaming, almost gave my friend my card to order for me so I could walk away.
Andrew McGee
★ 5 • 6 years ago
Amazing deserts! Great place to eat at! It’s a little pricey, however, well worth your visit. The pictures are of the regular sized oatmeal concrete and chocolate, cookies and cream concrete! I highly recommend eating desert here!
Dee
★ 3 • 5 years ago
This is a local place where you can get frozen custard until night 11 I guess. It’s a typical cheap ice cream place, where all the flavors are too sweet. I ordered a Sunday with chocolate custards and it was huge in portion with nuts and fudge. However, It was extremely sweet.
Lance Brown
★ 1 • a year ago
Went out of our way to go here. Had it several times before. I never complain online but so bad. We went here 9/21 at 9:45pm. Apparently a Sunday comes with no toppings at all, so it’s a scoop of ice cream unless you pay for said toppings. That’s not a Sunday. Then the Leroy Brown was watered down and has no brownie in it anymore. Super fail guys. Should have went to Braum's. In the photo I added the chocolate when we got home. Paid a dollar for the banana plus the up charge on waffle cone.
